I've just finished watching it and I don't think I've ever love-hated a movie more than this. I feel horribly depressed because of it. I feel like I need to reach out to someone, anyone, and give them a hug.
This is partly because the film is actually very painful and awkward to watch. It has this very wretched way of not showing what's actually going on but just shows the characters either being very emotional or very cryptic. Plus you get these fade to black transitions just when it looks like characters are about to open up to each other. The visuals are also intentionally depressing.
But it's all very well-crafted. And once you are prepared for the emotional tone of it, it is very rewarding to see the finer details in the acting and the story. And like similarly depressing yet cathartic films such as The Crow or The Road, this film makes you connect with the human beauty expressed within it such that it will haunt you with thoughts of what the characters are going through. This is no doubt thanks to the acting of one Aishwarya Rai, who is maybe at her career best here, portraying a living, breathing character like she's done never before or since. Ajay Devgan is good too, though the amount of restraint he imbued the character with is more infuriating rather than sympathetic, he almost comes across as the antagonist in this story. Something you might not agree with, but gives you something to think about as you come to terms with the story.
The rest of the cast is great too, bringing realism and gravity to the story and helping round out the main two.
In terms of being an emotionally wrenching experience, I'd put this film up there with Graveyard of the Fireflies. If you give it a try, you'll never forget this film and will feel an emotional wrenching wherever you remember it. This is art of the highest order.
EDIT: On further reflection I have to add that Ajay Devgan is actually also great in this movie. I found his character harder to appreciate because I wasn't prepared for it in the first viewing. As a fan of his work I was expecting him to play a more stoic, even aggressive character, so it was difficult for me to accept the more emotionally vulnerable character he was depicting so well in this film. I will have to make the time to watch this film again just to better appreciate the more delicate depth of it.
This is partly because the film is actually very painful and awkward to watch. It has this very wretched way of not showing what's actually going on but just shows the characters either being very emotional or very cryptic. Plus you get these fade to black transitions just when it looks like characters are about to open up to each other. The visuals are also intentionally depressing.
But it's all very well-crafted. And once you are prepared for the emotional tone of it, it is very rewarding to see the finer details in the acting and the story. And like similarly depressing yet cathartic films such as The Crow or The Road, this film makes you connect with the human beauty expressed within it such that it will haunt you with thoughts of what the characters are going through. This is no doubt thanks to the acting of one Aishwarya Rai, who is maybe at her career best here, portraying a living, breathing character like she's done never before or since. Ajay Devgan is good too, though the amount of restraint he imbued the character with is more infuriating rather than sympathetic, he almost comes across as the antagonist in this story. Something you might not agree with, but gives you something to think about as you come to terms with the story.
The rest of the cast is great too, bringing realism and gravity to the story and helping round out the main two.
In terms of being an emotionally wrenching experience, I'd put this film up there with Graveyard of the Fireflies. If you give it a try, you'll never forget this film and will feel an emotional wrenching wherever you remember it. This is art of the highest order.
EDIT: On further reflection I have to add that Ajay Devgan is actually also great in this movie. I found his character harder to appreciate because I wasn't prepared for it in the first viewing. As a fan of his work I was expecting him to play a more stoic, even aggressive character, so it was difficult for me to accept the more emotionally vulnerable character he was depicting so well in this film. I will have to make the time to watch this film again just to better appreciate the more delicate depth of it.
Tell Your Friends