The truth is still out there, but I wish they would have put some of it in this episode. Aside from the familiar faces, and shadows of original story lines, there's not much recognizable as X-Files in this episode.
In place of the good story telling we came to love in the original seasons, here we just get all the terrible tactics of cheap television. Episode 1 was packed full of constant shaky cam, hyper close ups, quick cuts, and strobe lighting effects. In other words you'll get all the nausea and headaches you want, and because its so chopped up you won't have a clue whats going on. Scenes that might have been able to be salvaged in editing were cut up and shuffled together in a way that felt unnatural, non-nonsensical, and frankly annoying.
However, the absolutely worst offense of the new season has to be the soundtrack. There was obviously zero attempt made to bring the quality, sound, or mood that Mark Snow brought in years past. If you went by sound alone, you would have no idea this was an X-Files episode. Those behind this soundtrack made a poorly written and directed episode truly unwatchable. It felt like it was a canned soundtrack that was hastily thrown together and intended for another show. Mark Snow's work was brilliant and recognizable even years later by anyone who'd ever seen the show. This episode was a strange, annoying, inappropriate noise that never let up. When scenes would finally end there was a sense of relief, and thankfulness that it was finally over.
As someone who has been a faithful fan of the series, owner of the entire disc sets including movies, I really tried to like the new work. However, it was so bad that it took me 4 attempts on different days just to make it through the first episode. Each time I tried to watch, I had to stop because it was genuinely painful to witness.
With all the terrible directing, writing, editing, and soundtrack, the original cast actors delivered respectable performances. However, everyone else should be banished from ever working in Hollywood again. Ever.
I fear this is so bad that it will taint the reputation of the franchise, the actors, and the fans. I am genuinely shocked they released material this poorly made.
I'm generously giving this a rating of 2 out of respect for the show, the talent, and the legacy.
Note to the money behind this work: What were you thinking? Did you even view this before it was released? If you found a competent editor you might have saved some humiliation for the show. You've seen the audience feedback on tricks like shaky cam, hyper closeups, quick cuts, and yet you packed this show with them? Were you trying to sabotage the show? The editing of the car chase scene alone could probably win the worst scene ever award. This episode is a painful embarrassment and you made it happen.
3 out of 10 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends