This review contains both spoilers and scorn.
Russel T. Davies was the writer of most of the emotionally relevant and grown-up episodes in the whole of 60 years of the Doctor. And he wrote this garbage.
What can I say? I am not disappointed, just angry with myself for wasting more time with the incresingly increpid and vapid stories of a person, who has been goobled up by itself, in story as well as in real life. There is nothing left, hollow inside and out, no longer any charm or purpose or meaning to it all. Please just go ahead and do the sad turd in - it has had its day. And it was not this day. Not by a long shot.
I guessed the story the second I saw the alien. The oldest trope in the book: Don't judge a book by its (fluffy, soft) cover. And self-assuredly the doctor comes to rescue the day like a TimeLord messiah, rather than the paradoxically unruly narcissist almost incapable of not loving.
Speaking at the level of another turd of mr. Davies, Wizards vs. Aliens, in simplistic terms: It talks down to people. Mr. Davies can only write for adults - dumbing down invariably leads him to speaking louder, when meeting a deaf person - he. Lets. You. Know. What. Is. Happening. As. If. You. Are. Dumb. Pun intended.
It is just SO bad. The 2 previous doctors have been some of the worst writing - everything steven moffat touches turns to imbicile crap not even fit for young people.
Examples? Compare the latter half of Russel T. Davies' work, including Torchwood, with the whole of Steven Moffats as writer for Doctor Who. Moffat cannot not hold a candle to the sensitivity and depth and vision and exuberance and pain and real drama of Davies. All of Moffat's work is just shell - nothing inside. Lines come out emptly, and Oh, how Capaldi struggled with the material - what ever possessed the man to stay on, I will never understand. And Jodie Wittaker... that was just embarrassing. But now Russel T. Davies is infected byt the same bug, that will rot away at children's brains: The inability to respect and understand drama, thus being made ready for the forcefeed of adult crap served on every channel and seen in most movies and series and books and plays.
The collective dumbing down of a generation, and what better vehicle than a popular show spanning generations!
Actually this could be a relevant synopsis for a Doctor Who arc from the good days. "The Lost Generations".
Sad.
Russel T. Davies was the writer of most of the emotionally relevant and grown-up episodes in the whole of 60 years of the Doctor. And he wrote this garbage.
What can I say? I am not disappointed, just angry with myself for wasting more time with the incresingly increpid and vapid stories of a person, who has been goobled up by itself, in story as well as in real life. There is nothing left, hollow inside and out, no longer any charm or purpose or meaning to it all. Please just go ahead and do the sad turd in - it has had its day. And it was not this day. Not by a long shot.
I guessed the story the second I saw the alien. The oldest trope in the book: Don't judge a book by its (fluffy, soft) cover. And self-assuredly the doctor comes to rescue the day like a TimeLord messiah, rather than the paradoxically unruly narcissist almost incapable of not loving.
Speaking at the level of another turd of mr. Davies, Wizards vs. Aliens, in simplistic terms: It talks down to people. Mr. Davies can only write for adults - dumbing down invariably leads him to speaking louder, when meeting a deaf person - he. Lets. You. Know. What. Is. Happening. As. If. You. Are. Dumb. Pun intended.
It is just SO bad. The 2 previous doctors have been some of the worst writing - everything steven moffat touches turns to imbicile crap not even fit for young people.
Examples? Compare the latter half of Russel T. Davies' work, including Torchwood, with the whole of Steven Moffats as writer for Doctor Who. Moffat cannot not hold a candle to the sensitivity and depth and vision and exuberance and pain and real drama of Davies. All of Moffat's work is just shell - nothing inside. Lines come out emptly, and Oh, how Capaldi struggled with the material - what ever possessed the man to stay on, I will never understand. And Jodie Wittaker... that was just embarrassing. But now Russel T. Davies is infected byt the same bug, that will rot away at children's brains: The inability to respect and understand drama, thus being made ready for the forcefeed of adult crap served on every channel and seen in most movies and series and books and plays.
The collective dumbing down of a generation, and what better vehicle than a popular show spanning generations!
Actually this could be a relevant synopsis for a Doctor Who arc from the good days. "The Lost Generations".
Sad.
Tell Your Friends