Reviews

3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Forensic Files II: Human Sawdust (2020)
Season 1, Episode 4
8/10
Sawdust and Sociopathy
3 March 2020
The story here is a good one, since this case was a famous murder prosecution in New Jersey earlier this century.

If you want to see a story of a murderer with ice-cold blood, watch this episode. Please take note of the MURDERER'S JOB when you watch. It will make you wonder the next time you may have to interact with someone in that job. It's chilling.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Forensic Files II: The Green Pen (2020)
Season 1, Episode 3
6/10
Good Story But Bad Narration
2 March 2020
This episode has a good story that investigates the murder of a college student. It shows you the steps the investigators took to find evidence of who did it. The murderer was quite stupid and the cops figured it out pretty fast.

It's good that they have made new episodes, but the change they made in the series, overall, is VERY bad and it casts a pall over the ENTIRE new series of episodes.

NBC has the crime show "Dateline NBC", narrated by Keith Morrison, who either has as his natural voice or deliberately puts on as his narration voice an overly dramatic voice. Many (probably most) people find it to be irritating. Keith Morrison has been the object of ridicule on Saturday Night Live and other shows.

Unfortunately, the makers of Forensic Files II seem to think Keith Morrison's narration is something good and have sought to emulate it! That is a stunning and annoying development. Are they unaware that people dislike the way Keith Morrison speaks?

The man they have employed to narrate these new episodes seems to be imitating Keith Morrison in his intonation, cadence, and overly dramatic speech patterns. I am sure that plenty of people will find it to be annoying in the same way that many people have found Keith Morrison to be annoying.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Columbo: Rest in Peace, Mrs. Columbo (1990)
Season 9, Episode 4
8/10
A Case of Obsession and Psychosis
26 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This episode is unusual in that it is one of the newer episodes that is somewhat good. I find many of the newer episodes to be not as good as the older ones, since they don't follow the formula of the 1970's episodes and stray too far, sometimes, into typical crime-show territory. The episode "No Time to Die", from 1992, is one that strays very far from the formula and that many regard as one of the worst.

One issue in my mind with this episode is that Columbo is hounding a person who is not mentally all-there. Usually, we root for Columbo because he's catching an evil calculating person who usually deserves to be locked up, although there are certainly episodes where the "murder" we see is accidental, in my opinion, or not as evil as other murders.

In this episode we have a woman who murders the man who helped put her husband into prison, and then plans to get rid of Columbo's wife and Columbo himself. As we see throughout the episode, she has an obsession with her husband's death, irrationally blames people other than her husband for his conviction, and (metaphorically, maybe) plays recordings of actual or imagined conversations in her head regarding the case of her husband. Those "recordings" may represent auditory hallucinations.

To me, she is suffering some psychosis and, as the reviewer "stubbers from Essex" says, Columbo knows "full well that she is insane." Dr. Steadman, Vivian Dimitri's psychiatrist, says she has an "obsession" and Columbo says that he read a book with a case history of a person exhibiting "psychotic behavior" to learn about Vivian Dimitri's mind. Dr. Steadman tells Columbo that the case history he read does match Vivian Dimitri's behavior.

I think the reviewer "Harry Smart from United States" gets it wrong by saying, "there are psychopaths like that in the real world." Untrained people constantly throw around words like "psychopath" and "schizophrenic" without any idea of what they mean. Vivian Dimitri is, to me, psychotic and definitely NOT psychopathic. A better example of a psychopath would be former President Bill Clinton, as a number of psychiatrists pointed out while he was in office. A significant number of presidents and CEOs are psychopaths and it plays an essential part in them achieving their successes. Have you spoken to more than a few police officers in your lifetime? Then you've more than likely met a psychopath. Police is one of the top ten professions that employ psychopaths. Vivian Dimitri is certainly not an example of a psychopath.

My guess is that a defense attorney would seek to have her found unfit for trial.

I didn't give this a 10 since I feel sorry for Vivian Dimitri. She is not as clearly evil and cold as Robert Culp or Jack Cassidy were in their 6 episodes as murderers.
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed