Reviews

To me this movie was entertaining far from a classic. Agar said he dsid it for the money. It was atmospheric with the fog special effects. One question that haunts me to this day where did they get the stripped coat that Agar wore in the movie. I've sat through worse.

I am not a critic and I'm far from being one. I really enjoyed this short. Ben Blue love him or hate him he had his own style of comedy. To me if a comic makes me laugh he's doing his job. Both Ben and Shemp Howard are playing off each other pretty well here. I'm a sucker for comedy shorts. Both did their jobs in this short.

This has been a real treat watching this little gem. If I could rated it higher I would without hesitation.

I read the reviews on this movie before I saw it .I said wow warning bad reviews but I'll take chance. Mainly I see a movie to get entertained not to nitpick it. This movie filled the bill. At least it didn't put me to sleep. Everyone did a good job.

In short great cat and mouse episode. Nice to see the old Pike in the background in this episode.

This a little gem of a movie. Honesty with tears laughter mixed in. Well done.

I WILL MAKE THIS SHORT. SEE IT , ENJOY IT THIS IS A CLASSIC. OTHER REVIEWERS SAID IT WAS TOO LONG , BUT IT IS LIKE COOKING ITALIAN SAUCES THE LONGER YOU COOK IT THE BETTER IT TASTE. WATCH OUT FOR OSCAR NOMINATIONS AND WINNERS HERE. MR. SCORESE WELL DONE ALL THE WAY AROUND BRAVO !!!

I SAW THIS MOVIE ON TV IN 1957, I WAS 10 THEN. THE MOVIE WAS JUST A MOVIE UNTIL THE ENDING WHEN THE BOYS WERE WALKING UP IN THE CLOUDS AND THE MUSIC WAS PLAYING ANCHORS AWAY, THIS WAS THE FIRST MOVIE I CRIED AND I MEAN CRIED. FAST FORWARD WHEN I BOUGHT THE VHS IN THE 80'S I CRIED. FAST FORWARD TO 2015 BOUGHT THE DVD I CRIED. THIS WAS A VERY TOUCHING MOVIE WATCHING IT MADE ME FEEL LIKE BEING PART OF THE SULLIVAN FAMILY FROM BEGINNING TO THE END. IF YOU CRY WATCHING IT YOU WERE NOT ALONE. THOMAS MITCHELL SHOULD HAVE BEEN NOMINATED FOR AN OSCAR. I WILL WATCH IT AGAIN AND AGAIN I WILL CRY. I SUGGEST GETTING THE 2 DVD DISC WHICH WILL SHOW YOU THE REAL SULLIVANS AND EXTRAS. REMEMEMBER IF YOU CRY YOU ARE ONLY HUMAN.

I WILL MAKE THIS SHORT (NO PUN INTENDED) BY THE TIME THIS WAS RELEASED IN MAY OF 1956 SHEMP WAS ALREADY LAID TO REST HE DIED NOV 1955. THE FIRST PART OF THIS SHORT WAS SHEMP WITH NEW FOOTAGE. THE LAST HALF WAS STOCK FOOTAGE TAKEN FROM THE STOOGES SHORT WHO DONE IT FROM 1949. HONESTLY I FEEL CHEATED WHEN COLUMBIA USE STOCK FOOTAGE, BUT IN THIS CASE I WILL GIVE THEM A BYE.THE SHORT DEPARTMENT HAD TO DO WHAT THEY HAD TO DO TO SURVIVE THE COLUMBIA. BUDGET AND HARRY COHN. I LIKE THIS SHORT, IT IS KIND OF A TRIBUTE TO SHEMP. REST IN PEACE SHEMP

SAW THIS MOVIE IN 1957 WHEN I WAS 10 ENJOYED IT THEN. STILL ENJOY TODAY.....FUN MOVIE . GRAB THE POPCORN

ANOTHER ABOVE AVERAGE ALLIED ARTISTS MOVIE GOOD FUN MUNCH ON SOME POPCORN LAY BACK AND ENJOY !

AND THANK GOD THEY DID . A TRUE GEM SHORT AND SWEET. DO YOURSELF A FAVOR AND GO SEE THIS MOVIE !!!

I FIRST SAW THIS MOVIE IN 1958 WHEN I WAS 10 ATA LOCAL THEATER, THE OPENING SCENE SCARED THE HELL OUT OF ME I REMEMBER THIS BECAUSE I DROPPED MY SODA AND POPCORN. I GAVE IT A 7 IT WAS ENTERTAINING. SURE IT WAS LOW BUDGET ETC ETC ETC. IF YOU SEE IT FOR THE FIRST TIME DON'T DROP THE POPCORN !