Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
I expected more...
27 December 2006
Warning: Spoilers
...after having read some positive reviews. I watched this movie and was deeply disappointed, as it totally lacks the kind of humor, which makes better (and older) czech comedies so great.

The idea of a group of totally different people, e.g. two old ladies, a famous singer, a redneck family or a gay couple travelling to the same holiday ressort isn't new at all, but still offers numerous opportunities to make a good or -at least- a funny film. The makers of "Ucastnici" didn't take them, but tried to make some sort of an "American Pie"-clone, with a lot of unnecessary sex (the eleven-yr. old son of the redneck is afraid of becoming gay, so one of the female members of the group lets him touch her breasts, in order to convince him that he is "straight".) and drugs (one of the gays brought some weed, everybody's stoned and one of the older guys refers to the "60's" as if there never was a soviet invasion in Czechoslovakia in '68 but just some big Hippie-happening).

To make a long story short, the times of high-quality czech cinema seem to over, due to lack of money but mainly due to the lack of interest. Why should an audience, that for nearly twenty years lives in a post-communist society, still stick to it's old values like excellent actors, subtle humor and a deep humanity, when it's so much easier to copy the most stupid of US and German "comedies"? I'm sad.
4 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A very interesting movie...
1 May 2006
...at least for those viewers with detailed knowledge of the historical context. The acting is mediocre, true, but that wasn't important for me, as I really enjoyed the sensitive approach towards the feelings and the motivation of the young students. Imagine the pre-WWI values, nationalism, the good old "right or wrong, my country", and imagine the tensions on the Balkan peninsula, the rising serb nationalism, two years after the liberation of Kosovo, the "serb Jerusalem", as some call it even today. Think of the cheering masses at the train stations at the beginning of the war, the cars decorated with flowers and crowded with soldiers on their way to the fronts. One nations honor was considered to be worth dying and killing for, and Archduke's Ferdinands visit to Bosnia was widely regarded as (and intended to be) a provocative act.

I recommend to read Ivo Andric's "The Bridge on the Drina", it's last chapters also deal with students of a very similar background (and similar fate).

OK, it's a movie about an assassination, but without showing it. Where's the problem? This is not an action movie, this is "art" :-) A shooting scene with bad stunts, cheap effects etc... would ruin the movie instead of enhancing it.

By the way, i liked the music

P.S. I just ordered the novel...
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed