There are a lot of great things about this show. The production is masterclass, the acting is very solid and it's just a great time. In fact I binged the show in 3 days while being quite busy, I was completely hooked. So it obviously does somehting right.
The show starts out extremely strong, in fact the first two or three episodes are probably straight 10 out of 10s. Entertaining, touching, just a really solid drama. Beth is an interesting protagonist. I saw a lot of complaints about her being quite one-tone but I think that is only the case on her outside, there's a lot more to her than meets the eye. Despite having a brilliant mind, she struggles with her personal life and has trouble adjusting to the world. I liked the coming of age aspect of her story too.
However by the mid-point of the series, I started to notice some irratiting flaws. It's kind of strange but despite her tough life, I never felt like Beth had to really do much to solve issues. When she loses a march, she broods for a bit and then just proceeds to win the rematch despite not really doing much to get better. She loses her step-mother, struggles with addiction but I never felt like she truly hit a rock bottom from which she clawed back up herself. It was always other characters pulling her up, showing up at convenient moments. And it's not like she earned their friendship or help in some way. All the male characters are just helping her because they are attracted to her.
As an example, when Beth goes off the deep end in episode 6, Jolene miraculously shows up and all it takes for Beth to get back on her feet is to visit the orphanage again. It kinda works but there was potential for something more interesting. I don't know, I just feel like everything was always way too easy for her. It cheapens the wins.
Then we get to the ending which was way too cheesy for me. Her beating Borgov is fine but Townes showing up out of nowhere made me roll my eyes. What the hell was the point anyway? It's not like he gives her some game-changing insight, by that point, she had all but defeated her opponent anyway.
So overall I am kinda mixed. The start is truly incredible and made me hooked but I was left disappointed by the latter half of the show. There was potential for something truly incredible. But despite my criticisms I still enjoyed watching it a lot if only for the incredible acting and production. I can definitely see why it's such a popular show.
3 out of 4 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends