7/10
A very different type of western
23 December 2004
Warning: Spoilers
McCabe and Ms. Miller focuses on two 'undesirable' characters that were mainstays of the American frontier, but have rarely been represented in the Western movie genre: the gambler and the madam. However, this movie goes to show how important these two were in shaping the West. Ultimately, the promise of the open west as a land for entrepeuners is wiped out by the corporate monopolies. Civilization comes in and has no room for the independent businessman.

At least, thats what I took from this movie. Style-wise, the photography and location are excellent. The acting, especially Julie Christie, is very good as well.

Personally, I find Altman to be both infuriating and fascinating as a director. His very loose style, filled with mumbles and multiple conversation, requires very active participation from the viewer. However, for whatever reason, his movies feel incomplete to me. Maybe, because you feel more like you and Altman are evesdropping on a scene, rather than being led through a narrative.

Plus, the ending is a real downer!
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed