I consider Chaplin a true movie master. I enjoyed "The Gold Rush" and "Modern Times," and think that "City Lights" is one of the five best movies I have ever seen. So I think I definitely "get" Chaplin.
All that being said, I can see why "The Circus" is often overlooked when discussing his films. I suppose it's blasphemous to criticize ANY Chaplin film (as I write this comment, not even one lukewarm review has been written for this film), but I think this film lacked pathos and depth. Certainly nothing wrong about this film, but nothing really great about it either. For me, it's not the humor that makes Chaplin's films so great, it's the pathos. And in "The Circus," I think he failed to pull this off.
All that being said, I can see why "The Circus" is often overlooked when discussing his films. I suppose it's blasphemous to criticize ANY Chaplin film (as I write this comment, not even one lukewarm review has been written for this film), but I think this film lacked pathos and depth. Certainly nothing wrong about this film, but nothing really great about it either. For me, it's not the humor that makes Chaplin's films so great, it's the pathos. And in "The Circus," I think he failed to pull this off.