5/10
Outdated.
14 July 2009
I'm not too sure what the big deal is about this film. I love the work of a Master as much as the next guy, in this case Bunuel, but I fail to see the genius in this picture. Frankly, it's a little outdated. It's got that old style Hollywood lighting and acting style that is way over the top and unbelievable. The effects are terrible, and I know, it was 1962..but still, they seem lame. Also, it's not as surreal as other commenters would lead you to believe. And I didn't really see it as that biting of a commentary on the upper class. Is that really that important of a criticism anyway? And didn't Bunuel do it with multiple other movies as well? I would recommend those, his later works, before this film. The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie is a better take on the same themes. Belle De Jour is far more interesting Bunuel, I would check that out first. I was very hesitant to criticize a film by a great director but I decided to go for it because it may save people some time. Just my two cents...
17 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed