There's a lot of mystery involved with this movie - certainly enough to keep you watching, even if silent movies aren't exactly your favourite. The story revolves around "The Brotherhood" - some sort of secret society whose apparently self-appointed mission is to rid the world of men they consider evil - by murdering them. It's never clearly explained what criteria The Brotherhood uses to establish how evil a person is - or how they select their victims, since the world must surely be full of "evil" people. There's also great mystery - which is really left totally unexplained - about the victim - identified in the movie as "The Man Who Has Lived Too Long." He only appears in one scene - in the restaurant where he's supposed to be killed.
Along with those mysteries is the intertwining love story that really holds the plot together. Lilith is apparently (another mystery here) the only woman who is involved with The Brotherhood, and she's is the object of two men's affections - Forrest's and Farallone's. Farallone is played by Lon Chaney. When Forrest draws the assignment of killing the victim by being dealt the ace of hearts (which is how The Brotherhood decides who will carry out their assignments) Lilith agrees to marry him - increasing the rivalry with Farallone, and giving Forrest reason not to do the killing. In the end, love conquers, as Farallone sacrifices himself and the brotherhood to allow Lilith and Forrest to enjoy their lives together.
I would have liked some of the mysteries to be tied up, but they weren't. The story of love conquering was a bit too sweet, perhaps, but the performances were great - some of the best performances I've seen in the silent movies I've watched - not overly exaggerated but definitely making clear what was happening in the story. Overall, I enjoyed this.
Along with those mysteries is the intertwining love story that really holds the plot together. Lilith is apparently (another mystery here) the only woman who is involved with The Brotherhood, and she's is the object of two men's affections - Forrest's and Farallone's. Farallone is played by Lon Chaney. When Forrest draws the assignment of killing the victim by being dealt the ace of hearts (which is how The Brotherhood decides who will carry out their assignments) Lilith agrees to marry him - increasing the rivalry with Farallone, and giving Forrest reason not to do the killing. In the end, love conquers, as Farallone sacrifices himself and the brotherhood to allow Lilith and Forrest to enjoy their lives together.
I would have liked some of the mysteries to be tied up, but they weren't. The story of love conquering was a bit too sweet, perhaps, but the performances were great - some of the best performances I've seen in the silent movies I've watched - not overly exaggerated but definitely making clear what was happening in the story. Overall, I enjoyed this.