The first time this film was made it was 1934 and it was a precode of sorts entitled "Hi Nellie!" with Paul Muni in the role of the demoted newspaper reporter forced to author the paper's lonely hearts column until he can redeem his professional reputation. The idea was novel and anything with Glenda Farrell and Paul Muni is worth watching. The second time it was made it was 1937's "Love is On the Air" with Ronald Reagan as a demoted radio reporter who can't keep his mouth shut concerning his suspicions about a local gangster's involvement in murder. That one is notable as not only Reagan's first credited film appearance, but a starring role for him to boot.
The third time around this story is moved back to a newspaper, and this time it is Wayne Morris, workhorse of Warner's B picture unit, in the role as the demoted managing editor. This time his girl Friday (Janis Paige as Kit Williams) is involved with Morris' character from the beginning, so she is always supportive. In the original 1934 film Glenda Farrell plays the female lead, but one that is antagonistic of Muni's character throughout yet helps him just the same. Here the gangster behind all the crime and Morris' character's demotion is played somewhat unpersuasively by Bruce Bennett, who usually played rather oatmealish good guys.
I guess what I'm trying to say here is that these three pictures are not perfect replicas of each other, but by 1949 Warner Bros. no longer considers this story A-list material and treats it as such. For the gritty A-list version of this film see 1934's "Hi Nellie". For Ronald Reagan at the very beginning see "Love is On the Air". To see what Warner Brothers could do with this story a third time as far as adapting it to the times - post War America - see this film. Nobody could whip up a batch of celluloid leftovers and make it as palatable as 30's and 40's Warner Brothers.
The third time around this story is moved back to a newspaper, and this time it is Wayne Morris, workhorse of Warner's B picture unit, in the role as the demoted managing editor. This time his girl Friday (Janis Paige as Kit Williams) is involved with Morris' character from the beginning, so she is always supportive. In the original 1934 film Glenda Farrell plays the female lead, but one that is antagonistic of Muni's character throughout yet helps him just the same. Here the gangster behind all the crime and Morris' character's demotion is played somewhat unpersuasively by Bruce Bennett, who usually played rather oatmealish good guys.
I guess what I'm trying to say here is that these three pictures are not perfect replicas of each other, but by 1949 Warner Bros. no longer considers this story A-list material and treats it as such. For the gritty A-list version of this film see 1934's "Hi Nellie". For Ronald Reagan at the very beginning see "Love is On the Air". To see what Warner Brothers could do with this story a third time as far as adapting it to the times - post War America - see this film. Nobody could whip up a batch of celluloid leftovers and make it as palatable as 30's and 40's Warner Brothers.