I can't believe this is the fifth James Newill/Sgt. Renfrew flick I've seen already. "Renfrew of the Royal Mounted" kicked off the eight picture series in 1937 and the stories ranged from passable to downright hokey. This one comes down on the hokey side, with a whole slew of unbelievable elements that begin right with the opening scene. How is it, one might ask, that a one-seater plane can be rigged to crash with a pilot bound and immobile at the controls? The picture answers the story later, but the explanation takes it on faith that you can simply rev up a plane's engine and let it go to take off on it's own. Are you buying that?
Or how about when Sgt. Renfrew takes on the pair of thugs in the cabin early in the picture and they make their getaway through the main door. Not a couple of seconds later, Miss Louise Howard (Louise Stanley) enters the cabin by the same entrance, but she never saw the bad guys getting away? But the best has to do with the earlier plane crash. Initially, we see it go down directly into a large tree, but when the Mounties, Renfrew and Constable Kelly (Dave O'Brien) investigate the scene, the tree is gone, and there's no body!!! Just a pile of rubble.
So notwithstanding earlier comments on this picture by other reviewers, this programmer has little to offer fans looking for a solid story with a murder mystery at it's center. There are a couple of light spots with a character named Whispering Smith (Jack Clifford) doing a hard of hearing gimmick, but it gets a bit over done. The Mounties get their men in convincing fashion at the finale as Renfrew shoots villains Raymond (Karl Hackett) and Yuke Gradeau (William Pawley) out of the sky, but if you stay attentive, you'll note that it's a toy airplane that winds up crashing into the ground below. With everything else that happened, it seemed pretty logical to me.
Or how about when Sgt. Renfrew takes on the pair of thugs in the cabin early in the picture and they make their getaway through the main door. Not a couple of seconds later, Miss Louise Howard (Louise Stanley) enters the cabin by the same entrance, but she never saw the bad guys getting away? But the best has to do with the earlier plane crash. Initially, we see it go down directly into a large tree, but when the Mounties, Renfrew and Constable Kelly (Dave O'Brien) investigate the scene, the tree is gone, and there's no body!!! Just a pile of rubble.
So notwithstanding earlier comments on this picture by other reviewers, this programmer has little to offer fans looking for a solid story with a murder mystery at it's center. There are a couple of light spots with a character named Whispering Smith (Jack Clifford) doing a hard of hearing gimmick, but it gets a bit over done. The Mounties get their men in convincing fashion at the finale as Renfrew shoots villains Raymond (Karl Hackett) and Yuke Gradeau (William Pawley) out of the sky, but if you stay attentive, you'll note that it's a toy airplane that winds up crashing into the ground below. With everything else that happened, it seemed pretty logical to me.