2/10
Stephen Poliakoff = M. Night Shyamalan?
3 March 2013
Prepare yourself for six hours of bad writing, bad acting, and really, really bad music.

Writer-director Stephen Poliakoff has become the M. Night Shyamalan of British TV drama. He started strong, with dramas that seemed to be new and different and even (hideous new modifier!) award-worthy. Then, with each new project, his threadbare bag of tricks became more familiar and predictable; what once seemed endearingly offbeat became simply irritating, and Poliakoff's narrative deceits became increasingly obvious, no longer distracting us from his inability to create living characters or coherent plots.

The downward spiral has led to this sloppy, boring mess of a mini-series. Good luck getting through the whole thing, and if you do, you will almost certainly be disappointed by the limp ending.

Particularly irritating is the music. Poliakoff presumes to resurrect a largely forgotten era of British entertainment, but the newly-written songs on offer here do not capture the spirit of the originals. Not only are they displeasing to the ear and badly sung, but the viewer is forced to hear them over and over and over.

It is hard to see how Poliakoff's next project can be worse than this, but if the trajectory holds, he will find a way to make it so.
12 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed