5/10
When other reviewers say 'sweet', think 'twee'.
2 November 2013
Amidst a sea of black umbrellas, a blue umbrella falls for a red umbrella and risks everything to be with her.

Holy cow, just looking at the almost unanimously glowing reviews here you would think that The Blue Umbrella was a work of both pure genius and originality, revolutionary in terms of storytelling and in technical execution. It's not. It's an overly twee short blessed with excellent CGI animation that frequently verges on realism but saddled with a predictable narrative and a saccharine sweet ending.

I'm also rather surprised that no-one has mentioned just how weird it is to see umbrellas—inanimate objects with zero control over where they go—fall in love; it's a bizarre concept that just doesn't work for me (and one that raises too many questions in my mind about how they might take their relationship to the next level).

5/10, largely for the technical skill that went into creating such photo-realistic animation.
7 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed