10/10
All your favorite Mark Twain characters....and color too!
30 July 2014
Warning: Spoilers
No, this film has not been colorized, and looks as fantastic as David Selznick's masterpiece, "Gone With the Wind", which was in production as the same time as this. Selznick had utilized color successfully before with the original "A Star is Born" and the classic screwball comedy "Nothing Sacred", and must have believed that the color process would add to the sweetness of Mark Twain's most beloved tale. Unlike "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn", there was little controversy over subject matter, even if some of the material might have been considered scary for young audiences, which includes a murder witnessed by Tom and Huck and a sad sequence where Aunt Polly (May Robson at her most lovably irascible) believes Tom to be dead after he runs away. There's also the frightening confrontation between Tom and the villainous Injun Joe (the very scary looking Victor Jory) in a seemingly endless cavern, but goodness plays itself out and a legend of American fiction has ended up on the screen with great success.

The 1930 version, equally as entertaining, is not as well known as this version, which isn't as well known, either, as the other Selznick classics I mention above. Tommy Kelly is a lovable little prankster in the title role with Jackie Moran in good support as Huck Finn, not yet ready for his own big adventure. In fact, Selznick would have to forfeit that tale to MGM with Mickey Rooney in that part the following year. Both "Tom Sawyer" and "Huckleberry Finn" were later musicalized for Broadway, Huck's story, "Big River", in 1985 far more successful than the underrated "The Adventures of Tom Sawyer" which played extremely briefly on Broadway in 2001.

Life on the Mississippi comes to life vividly as Tom must contend with a bratty cousin (David Holt) getting him in trouble every chance he gets. This "Little Lord Fauntleroy" wanna-be is so obnoxious that you long for him to get his come-uppance, sort of the male version of "Little House on the Prairie's" Nellie Olsen. May Robson's Aunt Polly may seem somewhat cold towards Tom here, and even a bit abusive. But when she conks him on the skull with a thimble laden finger, it's presented comically. You really feel her guilt when Tom is presumed dead, and for good measure, the soon to be seen "Wicked Witch of the West" Margaret Hamilton is thrown in as the mother of Tom's pal (Mickey Rentschler) who is off on the island adventure with him.

Walter Brennan gets one of his great literature character performances as the drunk Muff Potter, accused of murder, yet obviously innocent. Jory's Injun Joe might seem a bit of a slam at the Native American culture, especially when he is referred to as a murderous half breed, but Mark Twain didn't pull any punches when it came to showing how life in the South was at this time. The presence of the little black boy (Philip Hurlic) who shows great emotion during his few moments on screen is extremely touching, giving a humanitarian feel to the way Twain himself wanted to show minorities, as people and not as products to be sold or exploited. Even if he did have racism embedded with him, it was outlined with a compassion that presents conflicted emotions.

There have been many versions of the Tom and Huck stories, but of all of them, this is the one I highly recommend above the rest. Beautiful scenery wonderfully photographed in color and a fast moving structure makes this a must for family viewing and certainly one that ranks as an all-time classic.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed