Review of All Wrong

All Wrong (1919)
when half an hour is more than enough
20 August 2018
It is part of the nature of things that a great many films from the silent era are now only available in abbreviated home-view versions. Made normally in 9.5mm for the Pathé-Baby (known in the US and Britaain as Pathescope or Pathex), although there were other systems, these films were not necessarily abbreviated but the reels were small (3 mins each) so you needed an awful lot of reels to make up a whole full-length full-length film. What is more the chances of that great pile of reels surviving intact until today are...well, judge for yourself. So such bonzer Pathé-Babys are rare to come across but they exist. I have watched, for instance Henri Pouctal's Le Vert Galant 1924 (retitled - Pathé-Baby also had an irritating passion for retitling which sometimes complicates identification - Henri IV) in a succession of innumerable little files that neverthless add up to about 85mins worth. The films that were made so for the Baby are I think likely always to be popular French films. Foreign films seem to have been standardly cut down usually to about 30 minutes.

Sometimes, as in the case of Heimkehr (1928) for instance (which does thankfully also exist in more than one full version) or Trenker's arctic disaster film Der Ruf des Nordens 1929, one wants to tear one's hair out at the inadequacy of the abbreviated version. On other occasions - and this film is I fear very much a case in point - one wonders at the end of the half-hour how on earth they ever managed to drag the film out for another half hour longer. Perhaps this was only ever a medium-length (35-40mins) film but that was already unusual by 1919.

The story is exactly as stated and quite frankly there is not any more to it than that. Supposedly it was a big success for Mildred David but one wonders since she seems to do nothing except look vaguely goofy throughout the film.

The MPPC claimed as late in the day as 1912 that nobody would want to watch a film longer than half an hour - a notion that signed a death warrant for most of the companies involved - but it is true that for some films thirty minutes is quite sufficient.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed