I was very excited to watch this series because the premise seemed intriguing and I enjoy shows that mix the personal and the larger aspects of life. The Scott siblings' back story is interesting and it's a good plot point to build on. However, Madeline's oversimplification of cases presented to her on the basis of her own experiences makes her appear emotionally and intellectually stunted and vindictive. This characterization of the protagonist may (and often does) alienate the audience. The show needs to strike a balance between the long running plot point of Rosemary's death and the Scotts' conviction in the case and the individual cases they pick up for each episode. For now, the treatment of the topic seems childish and unrefined.
Review of Proven Innocent
