The worst of all the alien shorts. Poorly directed. Zero atmosphere (excuse the pun). Bad acting. Every opportunity at suspense is ruined. At 12 minutes it feels more like 45. Even with all it's set pieces, and shot changes, it's amateur hour. I actually felt sorry for the production designer and set dressers who obviously had a lot to do with a limited budget. There just wasn't the need for so many setups.
With a decent director it might have worked. Embrassing. An insult to the Alien universe.