This is my very favorite episode. I love the story of Peter Pan, & I like how the story loosely followed that. All 3 boys (& Homer the dog) are adorable, & as I'm a mom (& a dog lover), they break my heart. I cry every time I watch it, especially when Rat says, "Goodbye, Wendy", & Melinda says, "Goodbye, Peter".
I do agree with the other reviewer's comment about leaving Homer behind, though. That IS just wrong, & I think that the only thing that would've made this better is if Homer crossed over with the boys.