The graphics and costumes are awesome. The soundtrack suited well. The actors are excellent. The plot is unique and creative. So why its a nine for me I had to to really think about it. I felt like there's not much chemistry between two the two leads. IU had great chemistry with the guy from the past better than the main guy considering it only shows as flashbacks. In the ending, it did not give me much of a heartache between those two leads when all the other characters who left made me cry. I thought it would have been better if the guy tried to stop her and tries to fight or wants to join her and at the end he must let go. A little bit of struggle would probably make me feel the intensity of their love for each other and feel their emotions. It was only IU who wants to hold on and the guy did not responded and just cry several hours after. It also don't make sense that they were together in NY maybe in reincarnation whether she remembers him or not. The Goblin ending makes more sense.
Review of Hotel Del Luna
