I've no idea what some of these reviewers were smoking when they wrote their claptrap.
This is one of the worst movies I've seen in years.
If the Uruk Hai had kidnapped the daughter and Smaug had decimated the city it would have been no less believable.
The old man was the only enjoyable thing about it.
If I could rate it zero stars, it would be too many.
Utter rubbish.