I went into this thinking typical Bachelor premise/trash TV - ESPECIALLY because it's by some of the same people that did Jersey Shore, but I was pleasantly surprised. Reality TV is always a spectrum of being contrived to flat out scripted, but I did feel a certain level of genuineness from this after a certain point. I liked how even though there was drama, there was a good amount of comradery especially among the two "Joes". I liked the occasional "breaking the 4th wall" moments. I feel like they actively looked at many of the things wrong with this genre and improved on some of it. My best recommendation is push through to episode 3ish, after that they seemed to get their own show voice. I think if you like reality TV, there's no reason why you wouldn't enjoy this show. If they do a season 2, I would watch it.
