While very realistic, I did catch two flaws that no one seems to have mentioned.
While there was some photography at the time, it is still unlikely that it would have been available to take pictures of the men to take back to the women.
When the women try to make themselves presentable to meet the men, it seems unlikely that after such a harrowing journey - and esp. At one point being told to discard all of their "pretty things" that they would have had nice dresses including some in still very white blouses, or in the shown time the ability to do their hair so nice. Are they shown bathing even?
And the men if they have been in the wilderness that long would they likely have had nice suits as well to meet the women in?
Up to that point though it seemed pretty realistic.
While there was some photography at the time, it is still unlikely that it would have been available to take pictures of the men to take back to the women.
When the women try to make themselves presentable to meet the men, it seems unlikely that after such a harrowing journey - and esp. At one point being told to discard all of their "pretty things" that they would have had nice dresses including some in still very white blouses, or in the shown time the ability to do their hair so nice. Are they shown bathing even?
And the men if they have been in the wilderness that long would they likely have had nice suits as well to meet the women in?
Up to that point though it seemed pretty realistic.