The first season of "The Afterparty" is somewhat similar to the concurrent "Woman In The House Across The Street From The Girl In The Window": both have an eccentric sense of humor and march to their own beat, switch genres from episode to episode (hint: pay close attention to the opening animated credits), do not always give audiences what they want, and sometimes sideline the crime investigation part altogether. The quality varies from episode to episode, with 3 being thoroughly brilliant (it demands to be seen more than once) and 7 being the weakest (perhaps the only time where a bold narrative choice does not quite pan out). Episode 1 is very sweet, episode 6 is very creative, and episode 8 proves how elaborately and carefully designed the whole mystery plot is. Overall the season is very enjoyable, and the whole cast works together beautifully: even minor characters like Indigo or Walt are great. The second season is about as good as the first on the whole: perhaps it has nothing on the order of S1 E3, but it may be more consistent, with just one weak spot (E6). It maintains the same mix of deadpan humor and intricate plotting (with every episode we gain new insights), and most of the genre homages (particularly the one to Hitchcock) are spot-on. The S2 finale certainly ties everything together neatly, yet I found it ever so slightly underwhelming - I expected something a little more shocking. I will still be watching any future seasons of this show made by the same people. 8/10.
Review of The Afterparty
