This review is for seasons 1-6
Season 1: I find this season one of or the best season of this. Most of the characters were either mildly likeable or very likeable. The challenges were arguably the best, and it was the best season for comedy.
Season 2: Season 1 but different setup and less characters. In some ways, I like having less characters. The writing got a bit worse, but it was pretty good.
Season 3: This is where the quality goes down. In both ways. The characters got more annoying, and the songs were super hard to sit through. I skipped through most of them, though. The humor was non-existent, and it was the worst of the original cast.
Season 4: New cast of characters and new twist on the island. The concepts were pretty hit or miss, most of the characters were ok, but some were well-written in my opinion. Other than that, it was pretty mediocre.
Season 5: A breath of fresh air. The characters are from season 1, 3, and 4. The concepts were new, and it felt like season 1 all over again.
Season 6: The worst season by far. The characters were very annoying and poorly written. I also felt like the quality dropped down in bushels.
Overall it is a 7/10.
Season 2: Season 1 but different setup and less characters. In some ways, I like having less characters. The writing got a bit worse, but it was pretty good.
Season 3: This is where the quality goes down. In both ways. The characters got more annoying, and the songs were super hard to sit through. I skipped through most of them, though. The humor was non-existent, and it was the worst of the original cast.
Season 4: New cast of characters and new twist on the island. The concepts were pretty hit or miss, most of the characters were ok, but some were well-written in my opinion. Other than that, it was pretty mediocre.
Season 5: A breath of fresh air. The characters are from season 1, 3, and 4. The concepts were new, and it felt like season 1 all over again.
Season 6: The worst season by far. The characters were very annoying and poorly written. I also felt like the quality dropped down in bushels.
Overall it is a 7/10.