Review of Stars at Noon

Stars at Noon (2022)
7/10
The importance of casting.
28 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
An ideal scenario for a Claire Denis film, with mystery, intrigue, cultural conflict and the interpersonal amongst the global political. However, this is not one of Ms Denis more successful and satisfying films. This is due to the casting of the 2 main leads. Margaret Qualley gives a brave and committed performance but she seems to be young and unwordly to inhabit the character she plays. Meanwhile her co-lead, Joe Alwyn, with whom she appears to have very little screen chemistry, has the charisma and screen presence of a concrete fence post. What a great pity that Robert Pattinson, a much more complex and accomplished actor was not available.

The film features fascinating themes relating to USA involvement in Central America, Coca Cola and the power of the mighty dollar. The relative status of cultural domination is referenced by the role that the English and Spanish languages play in the film and the ability of the different characters to speak either or both language. The supporting cast of NIcaraguan and Costa Rican characters are excellent and Benny Safdie makes a strong impression as a shady CIA operative/Business "Consultant" . As with all films by Ms Denis the soundtrack is great and the photography is wonderfully atmospheric. As ever, Ms Denis requires us to engage with the film intellectually as well as emotionally and visually and provides no convenient explanations. So I'm left with a sense of sad regret of what might have been if a better actor had been available to play the male lead.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed