The genius of this piece is that it really does allow Matt Walsh's subjects to speak. I've read reviews with accusations of "selective editing" so I watched it twice, but the truth is that people were allowed to speak expansively about their beliefs, and that those expressions were very much represented in the documentary. While I think it's true that Matt Walsh had his own bias going into these interviews, it takes nothing away from the testimonies we were allowed to hear. He basically ask questions and then listens respectfully to whatever answers each subject is willing to provide. Some interviews illustrated a marked lack of honesty on the part of the subjects, but some were astonishingly open. The segments with Scott Newgent were particularly poignant.
Review of What Is a Woman?
