I had to give a rating of 1 just to balance out all the hyped reviews.
This episode had far too much nonsense and felt like an insult to my intelligence.
First of all- why are the enterprise crew to believe they're in the "wrong" timeline just because it's not the one the viewer is used to? Every human believes they're in the "correct" universe, it's the other universes that should prove themselves worthy. And all of this because Guinan has an intuition about it? Who died and made her admiral?
Secondly who cares for Tasha Yar? The most blank character gets revived only to get an empty romance story and affect a past event that we learned is extremely important just 10 minutes before?
All of this for the main universe to end up as if this all never happened? Well then why'd it have to happen at all? An empty story entertaining an empty possibility that ended up affecting nothing from the POV of the original universe. And all entirely predictable from the very beginning. It's as if this episode didn't even air. And maybe that's what should've happened.
This episode had far too much nonsense and felt like an insult to my intelligence.
First of all- why are the enterprise crew to believe they're in the "wrong" timeline just because it's not the one the viewer is used to? Every human believes they're in the "correct" universe, it's the other universes that should prove themselves worthy. And all of this because Guinan has an intuition about it? Who died and made her admiral?
Secondly who cares for Tasha Yar? The most blank character gets revived only to get an empty romance story and affect a past event that we learned is extremely important just 10 minutes before?
All of this for the main universe to end up as if this all never happened? Well then why'd it have to happen at all? An empty story entertaining an empty possibility that ended up affecting nothing from the POV of the original universe. And all entirely predictable from the very beginning. It's as if this episode didn't even air. And maybe that's what should've happened.