A found-footage mockumentary set in 2003 follows an unconventional reality TV star, Tiffany Banks, as she struggles to prove her innocence after being charged with the suspicious death of her elderly husband and billionaire Herbert Eisenhower III. Elliot Cooper, host of "Unfathomable Conundrums." investigates the events leading up to Herbert's death, interviews close friends of Tiffany Banks, and the crime scene investigation by the NYPD. Various pulled footage from Tiffany's reality TV show is used to gather evidence to determine Tiffany's innocence.