The Old Corral (1936) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
21 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Roy Rogers to Gene Autry - "Put 'em up Sheriff!"
classicsoncall26 August 2007
Warning: Spoilers
This is one of Gene Autry's most easily obtained films, but if you pick up a recently made copy, you're likely to see Roy Rogers with equal billing on the video or DVD sleeve. It was only one of two times that the cowboy stars appeared in a film together, and since it was Gene's picture for Republic Studios, Roy appears uncredited as one of the Sons of the Pioneers. Actually, he might have been between names as it were. Born Leonard Slye, his name with the Pioneers was Dick Weston before he became Gene's replacement at Republic as Roy Rogers.

Smiley Burnette is on hand as Autry's sidekick here as he often was, his character was named Frog owing to that deep, low falsetto he sometimes uses. Perhaps the most unique casting decision of the film, after the fact of course, was that of Lon Chaney Jr. as a henchman for Martin Simms (Cornelius Keefe). It would be another five years or so before "The Wolf Man" would establish Chaney's name as a horror icon, but you know, he appeared in quite a few Westerns in his career, and some quite good ones at that, including 1952's "High Noon". You'll also catch him as a guest in a handful of classic TV Westerns as his career was winding down.

As far as the story goes, "The Old Corral" is one of those modern Westerns where the Old West meets a developing America with automobiles and electrical appliances in plain sight; I thought it was pretty cool to see a General Electric marquee during an opening traffic scene. I wonder if that was a little bit of early product placement, or just a consequence of being in the right place at the right time.

The plot has a story loosely built around a witness to a murder back East, with singer Eleanor Spencer (Hope Manning) attempting to maintain a low profile in an out of the way town called Turquoise City where Gene is sheriff. Actually, there are two sets of bad guys in the picture, with gangster Scarlotti (John Bradford) chasing Spencer cross country to eliminate her as a witness, while Simms and Garland (Chaney) try to ingratiate themselves with the singer in order to cash in with Scarlotti.

You know, I'll never be able to figure out why the shooting starts in a lot of these early 'B' oaters. For example, when Scarlotti's gang takes off in their car chasing Simms and Spencer, one of the gangsters turns and shoots at Gene during the Turquoise Day festivities. What would have been the motivation for that? - he could have hurt somebody!

Here's something to think about. When Scarlotti arrived at Turquoise City, he had five henchmen along with him. During the final confrontation with the good guys, Smiley shoots the driver, one is run over by the cattle stampede, and another is shown being shot and falling down (Smiley again). Presumably, those villains are as good as dead, but at the very end, all six are shown in jail together! No math majors on this set.

But I guess that's what made up the fun in these early films, with not much thought given to logic and reasoning. That, and a healthy smattering of cowboy crooners belting out the tunes. Gene was actually pretty generous in sharing the singing assignments here. While he handles his share, Roy and the Pioneers knock out a couple as well, and Smiley shows his versatility by playing an accordion and harmonica at the same time, while using his feet to bang a xylophone! Oh yeah, Gene and Roy both yodel too!
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A thrilling and satisfying old western.
Kieran_Kenney27 July 2003
Old Corral is a very enjoyable film. Gene Autry proves that he stands in a class on his own, showing good acting skills, a great singing voice (as always) and the proper energy that the role demands. Hope (Irene) Manning is pretty good as Eleanor Spencer aka June Edwards, but one can easily tell why most people still don't know her as a great actress. And, of course, Smiley Burnett is the quintescential Gene Autry sidekick, always a welcome screen presence as far as I'm concerned.

Since I do enjoy some country music, I liked the appearance of the Sons of the Pioneers, and a young Roy Rogers was supposed to be among them. I only really noticed him at the beginning, when he and his gang hold up the tour bus. After that, he drifts in with the background extras.

Then there's the action scenes. They hold up pretty well, although the immobility of the camera, some fairly transparent visual effects and clunky editing kind of hinder the climax from being as climactic as it could be. All in all, though, it's a good film that I recommend for anybody who wants to watch a enjoyable classic western.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Interesting to see Roy Rogers & Gene Autry in same movie
Frank193813 September 2003
Although the movie is typical of the "B" westerns, it is interesting to see Gene Autry & Roy Rogers in the same movie & realize the Roy surpassed Gene in popularity when Gene enlisted & served in World War 2 Gene actually kisses the girl in the final scene !!
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gene Autry, Roy Rogers and . . .Lon Chaney?
reptilicus19 April 2003
Only a year after starring in the action serial THE PHANTOM EMPIRE, Gene Autry was already a singing cowboy star. In this film he costars with sidekick Smiley Burnette and a young Roy Rogers, who does not get individual billing but is grouped along with the Sons of the Pioneers. A highpoint of this film is Good Guy Gene ordering Bad Guy Roy to yodel at gunpoint! Also in the movie is a young (29) Lon Chaney as the manager of a gambling hall who shows a very wide yellow streak when some big city gangsters decide to muscle in. Don't worry, Gene and Smiley will save the day and have time to sing a few songs too.
16 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Gangsters meet the singing Sheriff Gene Autry.
michaelRokeefe26 December 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Chicago gangsters arrive in town in their limousine looking for songstress Eleanore Spenser(Hope Manning). They want to silence the songbird, because she can finger them for murder. Local sheriff Autry will do his best to straighten things out. Deputy Frog Millhouse(Smiley Burnette)tries to find a safe place to hide the singer; while Gene is rounding up the singing O'Keefe brothers(Sons of the Pioneers), who were previously arrested and released to help in taking on the gangsters and run them out of Turquoise City.

There is always time for song during an Autry flick: Eleanore will sing "With All My Heart", "Sons of the Pioneers" will vocalize on "Down Along the Rio Grande" and Gene will sing "Money Ain't No Use Anyhow" and the title song "Old Corral". Note that another singing cowboy Roy Rogers is a member of the Sons of the Pioneers. Also in the cast: Lon Chaney, Jr., John Bradford, Charles Sullivan and Merrill McCormick.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A good Autry movie
state406 August 2000
This is a good Gene Autry movie.This movie has a young Roy Rogers in it.He plays a good (bad) character.He is part of a singing group called " The O'keefe Brothers" (The Son's of the Pioneers) and they provide some very good songs in the movie.Gene and Hope Manning also sing some songs.It has a pretty good plot to it as well.Smiley Burnett displays his musical ability and his comedy ability.It has a very short fight scene between Gene and Roy(guess who wins?).All in all an enjoyable movie.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A Historic Cowboy Meeting
bkoganbing15 December 2007
The Old Corral starts out a whole lot like the Bing Crosby Paramount classic, She Loves Me Not. If you'll remember chorus girl Miriam Hopkins witnesses a gangland murder and flees from the mob. Here it's Irene Manning who's a nightclub entertainer who sees John Bradford do the same thing and flees out west.

Well, those big city gangsters are way out of their element when they're tangling with Gene Autry. Of course not everyone in the west is as friendly as Autry. There's Cornelius Keefe and Lon Chaney, Jr. who recognize who Manning is before Autry does. They own the local saloon and under the guise of giving her a break, hire Manning to entertain, but in the mean time call Bradford hoping to curry favor with the gangland boss.

If that's not enough sheriff Gene has to contend with the Sons of the Pioneers and their lead singer, one Leonard Slye who play a brother singing group who take to being outlaws as a way to gain notoriety and a radio contract. Of course in two years that lead singer left the group and started putting out his own westerns for Republic and Herbert J. Yates under the name of Roy Rogers.

I agree with a previous reviewer that Manning's soprano and Autry's western twang don't exactly mesh. It might be why Gene mostly didn't go in for singing co-stars throughout his career, unlike his famous rival at Republic. Of course Gene didn't marry a co-star the way Roy did.

The scene where Manning is trying to make a go of saloon singing and falling on her derrière until Gene helps out is reminiscent of Jeanette MacDonald trying to sing for her supper in Rose Marie. Jeanette had a co-star though who was more suitable to her voice.

The Old Corral is kind of dopey, especially the bit about The Sons of the Pioneers. Still it's a great bit of history, an historic meeting between Gene Autry and Roy Rogers.
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
All In Fun Western
Rainey-Dawn31 March 2016
This may not be Gene Autry and Smiley Burnette's best film but it's not a bad movie. It's quite fun - really cute. What makes this film extra fun and special is the fact that Roy Rogers shows up as Buck O'Keefe - that yodel scene really cracked me up laughing. We also have Lon Chaney Jr as Garland - Simms partner. Makes for a fun film overall.

We get a few songs, some gun firing, a few punches and a cool cast. The story is a bit strange: A woman witnesses a murder and ends up in a town that is still more like the old west rather than modern (for the time era). Of course our singing cowboy and sheriff Gene Autry is there to save the day.

7.5/10
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Very weak
planktonrules11 July 2015
Despite the novelty of having Roy Rogers appear (very briefly) in this Gene Autry film, there is very little to distinguish this cowboy film. The plot isn't especially interesting and Autry doesn't sing anything particularly memorable or enjoyable.

The film begins with a mobster murdering some sap--and a woman witnessing it. Instead of going to the police, she runs--and ends up out west. Naturally she soon meets up with nice-guy, Gene and the two soon end up between a local gang of jerks (one of which is played by Lon Chaney, Jr.) and the gang from back east. Can Gene restore niceness to the land? And, will anyone particularly care?

I've seen a few dozen Autry films and would have to place it near the bottom. Even the usually likable Smiley Burnette and his antics are really subdued in this one and the action never really heats up. A slow-motion sort of picture at best with little to distinguish it.
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
More singing than western action
cashbacher5 September 2019
When you see from the box that this movie stars Gene Autry and Roy Rogers, it is immediately clear that there will be a lot of singing. The Sons of the Pioneers are also featured, increasing the amount of crooning that is done. There is some gunplay and swinging of fists, but not a great deal and all rather weakly executed. Gene Autry plays the Sheriff and, in a role out of character for him, Roy Rogers plays a villain, although not the main or worst one. The plot is pretty weak, a female singer is a witness to a gangland killing in the city and flees the area, going out west by bus. There she is befriended by a man that recognizes her and wants to make a deal with the mob boss searching for her. There is also a romantic flame kindled with Sheriff Autry, one of the feeders of that flame is their singing together. The purpose of the western environment is to provide the context for most of the songs performed by the characters. The Sons of the Pioneers are in jail, so they sing lamenting songs, Autry and Rogers burst out themes related to the west. Most modern viewers will find the western where the main characters do more singing than fighting rather incongruous. Yet, Autry, Rogers and others made their careers by doing just that and the public enjoyed it. Autry made enough wealth to buy a major league baseball team. With the high level of graphics and the demand for intense visual action, it is unlikely that something like the singing cowboy will ever be viable again.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Lon Chaney's second Western opposite Gene Autry
kevinolzak14 November 2023
1936's "The Old Corral" was the second of two Gene Autry Westerns to costar Lon Chaney Jr., not the main villain as in "The Singing Cowboy" but a secondary henchman who still gets a great deal of screen time. Autry comes to the rescue of yet another damsel in distress, songstress Hope Manning the sole witness to a gangland slaying that forces her to go incognito singing at a New Mexico saloon. Chaney's Garland is assigned to keep tabs on her, the big boss hoping to collect a nice reward for delivering her to the Chicago culprits. The best scene arrives early, Autry falling victim to a holdup spearheaded by none other than Roy Rogers, who at least assists in capturing the villains for a happy ending. Chaney's next Western, "Cheyenne Rides Again," would pit him against hero Tom Tyler, both actors feted to become wrapped up in their work at Universal in various sequels in the Mummy franchise.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great Autry/Rogers/Pioneers Outing
bozey4521 January 2008
This is a great Autry outing with a very young 24? year old Leonard Slye with the newly formed Sons of the Pioneers. One of the most beautiful of the Pioneers recordings is here "Silent Trails" to this fan a better song than "Tumbling Tubleweeds" or "Cool Water." The exterior scenes were the oft-used Iverson Ranch, very recognizable by the chase roads and rock formations. The town scenes were the Republic Studios western set which i think was new at this 1936 time frame. It became in the 1960's CBS Studio Center, back lot location for Gunsmoke, Big Valley, Cimmaron Strip and other westerns of the time. As far as Old Corral is concerned its a fine movie, some say hokey but not this fan. I'd rather see these than some newer westerns. Autry and the pioneers, Smiley and the rest are fine in the film. Only bad stuff to this fan were Oscar and Elmer, who I guess were maybe a radio duo or something similar at the time. Could have done without those two. They were in a couple of Autry films.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Fun to watch
edrog28 December 2005
It is fun to watch this old movie and see a young Roy Rogers as well as Gene Autry. Sure, by today's standards it is corny, but that is a lot of the fun. Plus, it is a history lesson of autos and buses of the time.

I like to guess where the outdoor scenes were done. Looks like some Lone Pine background in much of it. The music is uncomplicated and harmonic whichseems unappreciated today.

Another fun aspect of this era of Westerns is the blending of "modern" technology with the old west. A curious technical "error" can be seen when the brothers are behind bars in jail with their guns on.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sons of Pioneers musical number
frontrowkid200225 December 2008
"The Old Corral" became famous for its fight scene between Gene Autry and his future competitor at Republic, Roy Rogers, known at that time as Dick Weston. Rogers was part of the Sons of the Pioneers musical group featured in Autry's pictures. In this film, they play highwaymen (overland bus robbers) who also known how to warble a tune. While most of them are captured and put in jail, young Weston gets away and Autry has to go after him, not only for the robbery but because the group needs his harmony. After he is subdued, Autry asks him to yodel. Rogers then learns why he was captured. In the next scene, the group is shown singing "Silent Trail," a moving ballad about the passing of the old West. The sincere expressions on their faces as they sing compliments their harmonious treatment. They always gave their songs a bit more class than the usual "hillbilly" groups Autry had in his films, who had been taken from the National Barn Dance radio show.
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Gene and the Sons of the Pioneers to the Rescue
Mike-7642 June 2004
Eleanor Spencer, a nightclub singer, witnesses racketeer Scarlotti shoot down rival gangster Pearl. Spencer takes a run for it with Scarlotti and every newspaper from Chicago to Los Angeles posting notices for her testimony. She ends up in Turquoise City, where bar owner Simms recognizes her and decides to hold her for Scarlotti, who he hopes will give him money for turning her over. Simms is being watched closely by Sheriff Gene Autry, who decides to protect her. It's up to Gene and the Sons of the Pioneers (who held up Gene and a group of bus passengers in order to get some food money, even though they really wanted a radio contract) to save Eleanor from being taken by Scarlotti's thugs (who made the cross country trek). Very enjoyable western thats very typical of an early Autry Republic. Also interesting to see Roy Rogers holding up Gene early in the movie (something you don't see everyday). The climax was a little weak, and the songs were not integrated too well with the movie (Autry's country voice and Manning's operatic did not blend well in the barroom song). Rating, based on B-westerns, 8.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
One of Autry's best with a young Roy Rogers and the Sons of the Pioneers.
revran28 October 1998
Gene Autry and Smiley Burnett (Frog) are singing and croaking their way through another Saturday matinee. Look for a very young Roy Rogers (Leonard Slye) and the Sons of the Pioneers.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Autry, Chaney, Rogers in musical getaway
hines-20005 October 2022
Leading lady Hope Manning is on the run from Mike Scarlotti (John Bradford) and his mob. This was interrupted by Gene Autry's future rival Roy Rogers with Sons of the Pioneers in a hold-up. Autry is going to take them in for highway robbery in which Deputy Frog Millhouse (Smiley Burnette) quips. "They couldn't even find a highway." Martin Simms (Cornelius Keefe) with his henchman Lon Chaney Jr. Offer Manning a job singing in his Turquoise City saloon. The film was interspersed with good singing from Autry, Sons of Pioneers and a great duet with Autry and Manning. Good to see silent screen actors Milburn Morante, a veteran comedian as a farmer with car trouble and cowboy star Buddy Roosevelt.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Good Entertainment
Snow Leopard22 January 2002
"The Old Corral" has most of what you could ask for in one of these old Westerns, with good action and interesting characters, as well as the variety entertainment that you expect in a Gene Autry feature. It has Autry as a sheriff having to contend with a family of outlaws at the same time that he is trying to protect a woman on the run, and while the plot often lacks credibility, it's entertaining and moves at a good pace. Besides Autry, it has Smiley Burnette in one of his usual roles, and the supporting cast features brief appearances by Lon Chaney, Jr., Roy Rogers, and Edward Platt - quite an assortment. Certainly there's nothing remarkable here, but it's good entertainment that most fans of older Westerns will find enjoyable.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Just about all the fans will like this one!
JohnHowardReid30 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
In "The Old Corral" (1936), Republic managed to assemble such a fine cast into the fast-moving yet laden-with-musical-numbers script that even director Joe Kane was inspired to contribute some unusually stylish and super-competent work.

Mind you, this is a favorite Autry vehicle not only with me but with Roy Rogers' fans (the scene in which Gene forces Roy to sing is a classic).

Lon Chaney, Junior's fans are cheering too, although in point of fact, Lon has actually little to do.

Although cramming an unusual number of songs into 56 minutes (fourteen to be precise), a fair bit of action is also center stage, featuring fast inserts and exciting stunt work.

(Formerly available both on an excellent Echo Bridge and Platinum Disc DVD).
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Early Autry Programmer
dougdoepke29 October 2013
I wonder what theatergoers in 1936 thought when they expected cowboys and instead were greeted in the opening scenes by an urban nightclub. Good thing action soon transfers to cowboy country. Eleanor (Manning) is on the run after witnessing a murder in the city, and now fortunately she has Sheriff Gene looking after her. But there are baddies in cowboy country too. So Gene ends up battling two gangs instead of the usual one.

This is a very early Autry western, before, for example, Frog (Burnette) settled into his clownish comedy relief. Here he plays a deputy in fairly straightforward fashion. It's weird, however, seeing cowboys alongside the old-timey four-wheel flivvers. Nothing special about the 60-minutes. Just a pretty good mix of action and song. Still, I wish it were a better selection of tunes since the Sons Of The Pioneers are on hand to vocalize along with Gene. Also look fast for Roy Rogers as a cowboy henchman, along with Lon Chaney Jr. in a sizable baddie role before he became the definitive Wolf Man (1941). All in all, it's a decent Autry programmer with some interesting features of its own.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Probably typical of Autry
Wizard-82 February 2010
This is the first Gene Autry movie I've seen - I decided to give it a look seeing that it was paired with another movie I bought on DVD, and that it also had Roy Rogers, the other singing cowboy. In some ways, it is a strange movie. It takes place in a world that has gasoline-powered vehicles and other modern (for the time) conveniences, but at the same time it has cowboys on horseback acting like they are living in a world several decades in the past! There are other laughable parts in the movie, like really bad back screen projection and tires that screech on dirt roads. But most of the movie is pretty dull in nature. Even though the movie runs less than an hour, it is extremely padded, when more time should have been given to develop the story properly (among other script screw-ups, it never properly introduces the female heroine at the beginning.) As for the (expected) songs, most of them sound alike, and won't stick in your head for a second after they're finished. If you grew up with Gene Autry westerns and are feeling nostalgic, I recommend that you keep your rosy memories and not shatter them by revisiting this movie.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed