Melody for Three (1941) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
No medicine, but great music
bkoganbing30 April 2015
The fifth of the six Dr. Christian films finds the kindly old doc taking an interest in a young man he's known all his life. Young Billy Stanley played by Schuyler Standish is a violin prodigy, nurtured carefully by his mother Fay Wray who is a local music teacher in River's End. It's in the genes because Standish's father is the noted conductor Walter Woolf King who Wray was married to back in their salad days ever so briefly. Of course the young man doesn't know King is his father.

Practicing no medicine in this film but caring a great deal about the welfare of his patients, mother and son, Jean Hersholt stops at nothing to bring about a reconciliation after King's plane crash lands in River's End.

There is a hilarious performance by Irene Ryan as a rival music teacher who brings all her pupils to the hospital for an 'audition'. The din they raise would cause a relapse with any music lover.

The film begins with Brahms and ends with Brahms as some of his gypsy dances get a fine treatment. A bit contrived, but a fine story.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Doctor Christian Listens To The Violin
boblipton3 March 2021
Twelve years ago, Fay Wray was a music student in Paris. She got married and divorced to Walter Woolf King, then she returned to America to become a music teacher in Doctor Christian's town, and raise the son King never knew she bore. The son has grown into a violin prodigy like his father, and guess who shows up in town, engaged to Astrid Allwyn?

The next to last of the Doctor Christian series, Jean Hersholt is more an observer than a participant in the story, which includes a goodly amount of classical music and a pretty good cast. Schuyler Standish plays the fiddle pretty good for a 14-year-old.

The series could have gone on for more than one additional film, but Hersholt was getting tired of the role and movie acting; he would appear in only four more movies , even though he would continue on as radio's Doctor Christian until 1954. He still had his humanitarian work, as well as his translations of Hans Christian Andersen and scholarly work on his fellow Dane.

We may know someone because his face appears on a movie screen, but that is not the totality of a man. Jean Hersholt died in 1956 at the age of 69. Those privileged to know him mourned the loss of a good man.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A pleasant movie well worth a watch
Paularoc16 May 2012
Warning: Spoilers
It had been many years since I had seen a Dr. Christian movie and this one didn't disappoint. Dr. Christian has become friends with a local music teacher (Mary Stanley) whose son, Billy, is a gifted violinist. Many years ago Mary divorced the now famous conductor Antoine Pirelle. Pirelle does not know that he and Mary had a son. In a coincidence that defies credibility, Pirelle ends up in a small plane that crashes in River's End (Dr. Christian's town) and Dr. Christian is called in to assess Pirelle's injuries, which are minor but do require a couple of days of bed rest. He recognizes Pirelle and calls Mary (who is also a nurse!) to look after Pirelle. The rest of the movie is spent with Dr. Christian trying to get Pirelle, Mary Stanley and their son, Billy, back together again. Irene Ryan does a good job as a pushy, irritating music teacher and Schuyler Standish was quite engaging as Billy. I enjoyed the movie but found it jarring when Christian's housekeeper (played by Maude Eburne) with great conviction and sincerity tells Christian "Women have no brains. They don't think, they feel, etc…" Christian must agree with this assessment because he just ups and takes Billy to Chicago to try and reunite him with his father. This scene is, however, offset by the a-stereotypical little girl who likes model airplanes, is a practical joker and tells Dr. Christian, when he asks what she would like him to bring her from Chicago replies: "A slingshot." I did enjoy the music and especially liked the tour of the radio station and the scene with the sound effects man telling the tour group how some sound effects are made.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Too much music--too much meddling...
planktonrules26 February 2010
Warning: Spoilers
This is not one of the better Dr. Christian films. While it isn't the worst of the six, it's probably second to worst. This does not mean I dislike the series--for B-movies they were often quite entertaining. The problem here, however, is that like the final Christian film they included superfluous entertainment that had absolutely nothing to do with the Dr. Christian character or the format of the rest of the films. The sixth one involved a girl who loved to sing and wanted to make it big with her operatic voice. Here, a young violinists and his mother have dreams of him being a big-time concert performer. Both films featured too much of this and not enough plot.

The film begins with Christian doing pretty much nothing--nothing whatsoever. A local lady (Fay Wray) makes money teaching violin lessons and her pride and joy is her ultra-talented son. When an airplane fortuitously crashes nearby, it just so happens that the man in the wreck is a very famous violist AND happens to be the kid's father!! Now considering the man had no idea where his wife ran off to and didn't know he had a son, his arrival in this piddly little town is patently ridiculous--talk about contrived! Later, the mother disappears and the meddling Dr. Christian takes the boy to meet the father he never knew he had. In the end, there is a heart-warming finale and the boy shows off his talent on a radio show.

The bottom line is that the plot is ridiculous and the story has little to do with medicine. Christian's only real role is to be a meddler near the end of the film--apart from that, he's pretty much irrelevant to the movie.

By the way, although she was not billed, Irene Ryan (Granny from "The Beverly Hillbillies") plays a rather large role as a rival music teacher. Also, I didn't see her in the credits at all, but wasn't that Imogene Coco in a tiny role in the film? I know she later appeared in the series--and I am pretty sure she's here as well.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Heartfelt and sentimental performances with musical delights.
gilturk30 June 2006
I have finally found the title to this 1941 film after many searches! Now, if I could only find out where to purchase, or view this little gem once again... I vividly remember seeing this movie in the church hall of my small hometown, when I was 11 or 12 years old. In spite of the rattling and clicking sound of the Bell and Howell 16mm projector, the wonderful music in the soundtrack impressed me. The story was appealingly told and even as youngster, the emotional impact of the boy dealing with the divorce of his parents made me most sympathetic.

I was learning piano at the time and a friend, the violin. To our great surprise, the young boy in the film's finale dazzlingly executed variations on Brahms' Hungarian Dance No.5 - a piece my friend was attempting to learn. I hoped the credits would reveal the name of the actual performer, and then find a 78 rpm recording of it at the local record shop. I never did find it, but in time I did get to appreciate the art of the film's classical violinist, Toscha Siedel. His name is still well etched in my mind after nearly 60 years!

Another exciting portion depicted in the film was the boy visiting a large US city. While visitng a recording studio there, he was shown and demonstrated the new far fetched invention, television. My, I then thought of this as pure science fiction. There is not much else I can describe but these two special moments remain vividly in my memory. Now, to keep looking and praying it will be issued on DVD some day.. Dreaming? I hope not.

ABSOLUTELY DELIGHTED! NEWLY RELEASED AND DVD FOUND ON EBAY. AFTER A 60 YEAR WAIT, TIME TO POP THE CHAMPAGNE!(Revision Added July 4th,2006)
15 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed