You Will Remember (1940) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Make that 7.5!
JohnHowardReid15 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Songs: "Lily of Laguna" (Finglass), "Littly Dolly Daydream" (Finglass), "Soldiers of the King" (Finglass and chorus), "Sue" (Finglass), all composed by Leslie Stuart. Music director: Percy Mariotty. Sound recording: John Carter. Producer: Charles Q. Steele. Executive producer: Jack Raymond.

A Jack Raymond Production, released in the U.K. through British Lion. Rented to U.S.A. TV through Modern Sound Pictures. U.K. release: 8 February 1941. Australian release by British Empire Films: 2 October 1942. 86 minutes. Cut to 82 minutes in Australia.

SYNOPSIS: An initially slow-paced fictionalized biography of poor boy Kelly, who changes his name and grows up to be famed music-hall songwriter Morley. With the aid of his lifelong friend Williams, Morley makes it big with his catchy numbers, but then falls victim to the rise of the Jazz Age. Production numbers featuring the singing of music- hall artist Finglass are well done, overcoming the weaknesses of the sentimental screenplay. — The Motion Picture Guide.

COMMENT: Robert Morley's third film appearance was in this excellent British musical, based on the life of songwriter ("Lily of Laguna") Leslie Stuart. Not only does Morley give a splendid impersonation, he doubtless wrote his own witty dialogue (he is actually credited with the writing of "additional scenes" in collaboration with Sewell Stokes).

Emlyn Williams has a rather soppy role, but fortunately is not in the film all that much. The direction by producer Jack Raymond is disappointingly conventional, but nothing could dim Stuart's music and this, together with Morley's performance, make the film highly appealing.

OTHER VIEWS: Uneven film whose only consistent quality is Morley's fine performance. Script and direction have almost as many poor moments as good, but lovers of Stuart melodies will not be disappointed. Morley was quite young when this film was made and his make-up as the elder Stuart is not too convincing — but that is not his fault. Photography and art direction are quite serviceable, while the music direction and sound recording are absolutely first- class.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The quality of the music saves this film
trimmerb123410 April 2020
Out of curiosity and because it was very close to where i once lived, I paid a visit where this film was made: Worton Hall Studios, Isleworth . The original grand Worton Hall remains but is now in the middle of an uninteresting housing estate. Actual film stages of the era were often crude-looking crosses between warehouses and early aircraft hangers so I guess are not much missed.

Robert Morley in later years tended to play rather stereotyped roles - corpulent with an upper class accent. He let himself be frequently cast as, I guess an American audiences' vision of a rather ridiculous type of Englishman, possibly harking back to George lll In The African Queen he played a fat, pompous preachy but ineffectual and flaky colonial missionary. Morley was a very intelligent, talented and witty man yet this was not always used in his roles. Here a young Morley - sleek and corpulent - plays the young struggling down at heel composer Leslie Stuart not modifying in the slightest his native plummy Southern English accent to play Stuart who was of working class Irish origin (Charles Victor plays his father with a strong Irish accent), born in Lancashire. Stuart never, judged from photographs, appeared corpulent. Here Morley was simply miscast, silkily gliding through the role, nevertheless, as always, a pleasure to watch.

To me the redeeming feature and revelation is the quality of Stuart's music - at times very beautiful, at times brisk and stirring (the patriotic Soldiers of the King), and other times quirky taking on various current fads - American minstrel music for one. Others, catchy hit songs, I'm not sure any British composer has had this versatility and success. Is he to be compared to Sir Arthur Sullivan of Gilbert and Sullivan fame? It is surprising to read that he had been the composer of so many still familiar hit songs of his era.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Rags to Riches and Back Again
richardchatten1 April 2020
A straightforward musical biopic providing a nostalgic escape into the past from Britain's then dire current situation (although it does display candour that it's subject gambled away most of his money), probably patterned after the recent Hollywood Technicolor production 'Swanee River'. It has the novelty of a relatively young and dashing Robert Morley in a very rare lead; of which his W.S.Gilbert and Oscar Wilde are better recalled.

Among the supporting cast, Roddy McDowell grows up to become Emlyn Williams; while Dorothy Hyson plays Ellaline Terriss, who made a few films herself.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Musical tribute with a moving coda
shakercoola13 November 2023
A British biographical drama; A story about Victorian songwriter, Leslie Stuart, who escaped a life of poverty in Manchester, England, to achieve international success in the early 1900s before falling back into obscurity and hardship. This is a straightforward story, based on a true story of rags-to-riches, handled with candour and humour. Robert Morley is a good embodiment of the naive, confident musicmaker, and it's a delicate portrayal of the man who saw peaks and troughs in fortunes and suffered the changes in his reputation. There is good supporting performances early on from Maurice Kelly as Young Tom Barrett, the infant prodigy, and from Emlyn Williams as his loyal friend Bob Slater. The quaint and catchy Edwardian musical comedy tunes help to keep it bouncing along. But it is the film's final sequence that brings a special poignancy and a message that talent and good spirit never die.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Clicked but entertaining
malcolmgsw27 May 2020
Robert Morley plays Leslie Stuart as a bit of a chump.This is a typical riches to rags story of a composer.The passage of time is marked by Morley wearing a different wig.His best friend is Ellyn Williams who seems a rather full person.However the music is the saving grace
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed