The Master of Bankdam (1947) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Worth seeing
hwg1957-102-26570427 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
'Master Of Bankdam' is based upon a best selling book by Thomas Armstrong set in Yorkshire and concerning a family in the wool trade from the 1850's and onwards. The film mixes the commercial and the personal in the usual family saga way and though there are no surprises it tells the story well, covering a lot of years and a lot of incidents. Once you get used to the familiar cast speaking (some more successfully than others) in the local accent then it is a gripping story which makes the 1 hour 45 minutes running time go quickly.

The cast is excellent; Tom Walls and Nancy Price as the elder Crowthers, Stephen Murray and Dennis Price as the sons who don't see eye to eye, Linden Travers and Anne Crawford whom they marry and Jimmy Hanley and David Tomlinson as the grandsons, who also don't see eye to eye. Stephen Murray almost steals the film and his character develops most in the film. Murray was not a first rank star but gave some great performances in several films. Covering such a span of time it doesn't seem rushed though and there are some fine dramatic as well as touching scenes. It portrays the passing of time well with subtle make up and costume for the actors and through the props and settings.

There were several Bankdam novels but this was the only one filmed. The saga would make a good television series.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Trouble at t'mill
The-Other-Monkey30 October 2005
The life and times of a Yorkshire mill owner and his family.

Tom Walls plays Simeon Crowther who owns Bankdam Mill.

His two sons, Joshua, played by Dennis Price, and Zebediah, played by Stephen Murray, clash over the running of the mill. Zebediah's reckless attitude causes the death of his brother in an accident at the mill. Joshua's son, played by Jimmy Hanley, sets out to prove his father was killed by his Uncle Zebediah.

As you would expect, he triumphs and gets to run the mill his way.

A potboiler of a story with a lot of mutton chop whiskers and thee and thy dialogue. Likable all the same. Look out for a young Nicholas Parsons in a minor role.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Milled Edges
richardchatten5 January 2021
Veteran West End farceur Tom Walls in the title role adopts enormous sidewhiskers and a northern accent in this departure also uncharacteristic of it's director Walter Forde (another comedy veteran), based on the bestselling historical novel by Thomas Armstrong.

A sort of nineteenth century 'Power Game' shot in the twentieth and, alas, still relevant to the twentieth-first in it's critique of the sheer incomprehension and indifference of the 1% to the way their activities impact upon the lives of the 99%; their venal corner-cutting leading to catastrophe. (The impact on the mill of the McKinley Tariff of 1890 also highlights the continued vulnerability of the British economy to decisions taken in Washington.)

Tortoise Dennis Price and hare Stephen Murray are eventually succeeded by the young Tommy Handley, whose own son ironically became a Tory M.P.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
What? Again?
boblipton2 February 2022
Walter Forde's penultimate movie is a long, rambling, immaculately produced tale of the rise and fall of a family of Yorkshire mill owners. It has gorgeous black-and-white camerawork by Basil Emmott, a cast distinguished by Tom Walls in his next-to-last movie, Nicholas Parsons in his first, as well as Dennis Price, Linden Travers, Jimmy Hanley, Anne Crawford... well, enough talent in front of and behind the camera to make a great movie.

Unfortunately, it's one of those movies about in-fighting, led by Stephen Murray, who longs to be the big kahuna, and is willing to use fair means and foul. I've seen this sort of drama, both in real life and the movies far too often to be impressed by it any more.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Very nice way to get through Covid lockdown.
rxelex5 January 2021
Having lived all my life in the area the novel and film is set in I was eager to see this film and found it mostly very good and realistic with good characterisations and most quite acceptable Broad Yorkshire speech. Broad Yorkshire having its glottal stop 't' and its silent 'h' roots in the Hebrew language spoken by the wandering Israelites that became the Anglo-Saxon-Jute-Viking that populated the Yorkshire area before and after the Roman period. One jarring exception was the scene where the mill owner's son confronts father of pregnant girlfriend and the father speak quite posh English and the son Broad Yorkshire! Few scenes in the mill apart from the long one concerning the 'milling' of new woollen cloth needing longer time in the milling machine. The woollen milling machine being driven by belts off a steam engine and having two wide cogs close together through which the cloth was fed in order to make the fibres mat together to give strength and smoothness. Helmshore Musuem has similar machine. The scene of the mill collapsing due to the urge to install extra looms is good and seems to have been filmed in a genuine mill being demolished. The following scene of mayor and millowner's son colluding in covering up the reason for the collapse shows how business was and is done in small town business. The patriarch with his apparent Broad Yorkshire was played by Tom Walls who being born in Northamtonshire spoke a close version of Yorkshire's Anglo-Saxon and was therefore well able to stop his glottal and silence any aitches in his dialogue. It's well worth a watch to see real acting and a disappeared way of life.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed