User Reviews

I used to like Jimmy Edwards.I saw him on stage with Eric Sykes in Big Bad Mouse.I enjoyed his sort of bombastic comedy.However even he is defeated by this unfunny comedy about this impecunious Irish aristocratic family left nothing but debts in the fathers will.However it is believed their is treasure hidden somewhere in the house.So they have to take in paying guests which not everyone is happy with.Eminently forgettable.

The patriarch of a family in Ireland dies and and bequests each of his relatives with a sum of money. One small caveat, there is no money so they decide to take in paying guests, well half do and the other half try to sabotage the scheme. There's a host of British comedy stars but none of them really shine, least of all Jimmy Edwards.

This film seems to spilt opinion, though most of the reviews are not favourable. Is this a tedious museum piece or a neglected treasure? The truth is neither, but it is a watchable comedy with some amusing moments. The premise sees the grown up children of the rakish Sir Roderick Lyall gather at Ballyroden Hall for the reading of his will after his death at the age of 95. However, they are in for a shock as although the old rogue mentions them in his will, it turns out he has spent most of the money on wine and women (so not wasted then), and what little is left will be swallowed up by debts. Even that will not cover the debts, leading to nephew (and seemingly only sane relative) Phillip (Brian Worth) having to give them the horrifying truth - they will have to take in guests to make ends meet! What's worst is they will have to take in American guests, with the first guests due to arrive that week. While some accept this ploy, others within the family do not and decide to sabotage their stay there in order to drive them out - forgetting that doing so will almost certainly see the Lyall family home sold from under them.

That is much the plot, though there is a sub plot involving missing diamonds or jewels that may be hidden about the house, while there are a couple of romantic sidelines, including a love traingle between Brian Worth's Phillip, his sweet Irish cousin Mary O'Leary (Susan Stephen with an Irish accent which is surprisingly not bad) and American guest Yvonne Cleghorn-Thomas, who spots him out the window one night and decides to set her cap at him. The plot is indeed thin on the ground, but it has to be said the cast play it with spirit and there are a few notable performances among them. Not least Jimmy Edwards, playing duel roles as both Sir Roderick and his unlikely named son Hercules, who is full of bombast about the proposed guests, but easily weakens when Phillip decides to ban him from having biscuits for a week. He is certainly memorable, but he is far better as the boozing, womanizing Sir Roderick Lyall, who appears only for the first 5 minutes but it is a rich charismatic character, from riding off on the hunt to returning on a stretcher and expected death, only to revive when he notices the "pert new maid" (Marguerite Brennan). His death decades later is highlighted by his extensive wine cellar, which the butler William Burke (Toke Townley) goes down to after Roderick's death, only to discover one drink left, having drank the cellar dry (he must of had a cast iron stomach!). Another notable mention is Martita Hunt (Miss Haversham from Great Expectations) as the eccentric Aunt Anna Rose. She is a true eccentric in every sense of the word, often sitting in a old fashioned sedan carriage for her tea or just to go on imagined holidays. She is certain she has mislaid valuable jewels somewhere in the house and eventually becomes key in the plot as the family decide the only way to save themselves from the debtors is to do their very own treasure hunt in the house in a bid to find them.

It's hard really to fault many of the cast for their performances, as they put in the effort to try and enliven the film. Irene Handl deserves a mention for her all too brief stint as Sir Roderick's maid and children's nanny, sparring well with Jimmy Edwards, but only seen for the first 5 minutes. Naunton Wayne (of Charters & Caldicott fame) at times has a gentle rapport with both Hunt and Brigid the maid (Maire O'Neill) and is a thoroughly decent chap who just finds himself lumbered with an American woman in Mrs Cleghorn-Thomas (June Clyde) and her sexpot daughter Yvonne (Mara Lane) - the former less than happy to be in what she considers a mad house. She's not entirely wrong there, either, and you can't blame her for wanting to up sticks and leave. Mara Lane does sexiness well enough as she tries to snare Brian Worth's Phillip, but there's little doubt in which way his inclination will go in the love triangle between him, Yvonne and cousin Mary. And considering Mary is played by the sweet Susan Stephen, it's a foregone conclusion for me and both Susan and Worth work well together. She even does a decent Irish accent, and her youth and energy is needed for a film of such a eccentric nature. Sadly that doesn't really come into it until the climax, but nevertheless it's still a harmless and inoffensive comedy of the old school. It may be sparse in plot, but the cast do their best to enliven it as best they can and I've seen far worse in my time. It may be flimsy, it certainly isn't outstanding, but it's a simple story with it's heart in the right place. And I'm always willing to give any film with Susan Stephen a go, even if at times she made more duffers than jewels in her career. She has certainly done worse than this!

Instead of coming up with my own, I'm just going to rely in part on the plot summary from IMDb: "Short of money, the owners of Ballyroden Hall must attempt to run it as a guest house, but not everyone is happy about the plan." In fact, some members of the household actively attempt to sabotage the effort to raise money as the first paying guests arrive.

I don't know what I was expecting from Treasure Hunt, but this wasn't it. I really hate to use this term when describing a film, but Treasure Hunt is horribly "dated". Maybe this kind of comedy worked in the UK in 1952, but it doesn't do much for me - and I'm a fan of older movies. Most of the supposed humor comes from the eccentric nature of Ballyroden's inhabitants In the case of Treasure Hunt, however, eccentricity is taken too far and becomes uber-annoying. I admit that I found Aunt Anna Rose, as played by Martita Hunt, mildly amusing from time-to-time, but it was near enough to make up for the rest of the casts' antics. I was at least hoping the titular Treasure Hunt might provide some entertainment. However, it doesn't occur until there are only 4 or so minutes left in the film. Overall, not a very enjoyable experience.

3/10

After reading these glum reviews I didn't expect much from this film, but I do enjoy vintage British comedies, so decided to give it a look on a rainy afternoon.

I was pleasantly surprised, mostly by the eccentricities throughout, in both characters and dialogue. Right from the beginning, with the play between the "lord of the manor" and the local poacher colluding to meet up for a night of poaching together, with the poacher calling the "lord" "you darling man", I found myself smiling.

This warm and silly film held my attention in a light and non-threatening way. Nobody was being murdered, there were no nasty surprises, it just did what a mainstream 1950s British comedy was meant to do: amuse and entertain. It's true it was no Ealing comedy, but it had its delightful moments.

Especially charming was Martita Hunt as Aunt Anna Rose, along with Naunton Wayne, Athene Seyler, Jimmy Edwards and the unfortunately underused Irene Handl, who is always fun to watch.

I am sorry for all those whose main comment is that the film is "dated". Yes, it's "dated", it's over 70 years old! Being "dated" is one of its charms to me, and I bet to many others if they give it a chance. It's a charming film and I recommend it!