The Perfect Tribute (1935) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Some remarks for the occasion
bkoganbing9 November 2019
Frank McGlyn who usually played Abraham Lincoln in so many films must have been busy so MGM took the highly unusual step of hiring burlesque comedian Chic Sale who was playing many grandfatherly types in his declining years as Lincoln. Sale does a restrained and dignified portrayal of Lincoln.

The short subject is in two parts first with Lincoln riding on the train to Gettysburg trying to compose a few short remarks for the occasion. He's with Edward Everett the main speaker and his Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton.

The scene then cuts to Lincoln visiting a hospital where he reads those remarks to a blind and dying southern soldier.

The Perfect Tribute was a well acted short subject from MGM.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The World Will Little Note
boblipton9 November 2019
In truth, the world didn't pay much attention to Abraham Lincoln's speech at Gettysburg. It was Edward Everett, the man played in this short by Claude King, who made the better noted speech. Everett was an orator in the old sense, fire, brimstone, orotund words. Lincoln's language was simpler, presaging the best of American writing, like Mark Twain or Hemingway. It was only with Lincoln's death and the .... well, calling it a cult would not be far off the mark.... that his genius for simplicity was remembered.

I guess Frank McGlynn, who had been playing Lincoln in the movies for twenty years at this point was busy. Chic Sale, specialist in old rustic types, gives a fine performance, but the makeup looks a bit artificial. Which, of course, it was.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
As White House Occupant #45 recently said . . .
oscaralbert9 November 2019
Warning: Spoilers
. . . of the Neo-Prussian wannabe oven-stuffer mob chanting crazed malicious slogans while wielding those ludicrous Tiki Torches during their murderous rally in Virginia Hell-bent upon kicking off America's second Rachel Civil War, "There are good people on BOTH sides." THE PERFECT TRIBUTE, if anything, bears an even greater imbalance favoring the malingering miscreant mutt side of the War to End Human Exploitation on the Part of Indolent Wealthy "Plantation" Owners Sipping Mind Juleps on Their Verandahs. Just as that bladder-busting yawn fest GASHED WITH THE WHIP would mangle history a few years following THE PERFECT TRIBUTE, the very same Perfidious Pachyderm Party Propaganda Purveyors responsible for THAT upcoming GWTW mendacious travesty besmirch the memory of the 19th Century's top War-Time President by making him seem like some cheap Game-Show-Host-in-Chief. "I know now what we're all fighting for: The love of country," sputters the unrepentant Genocidal Rebel "Captain Blair" to Honest Abe. Blair's crack is SO 1860! Not one word of contrition about the elephant in the room: The horror of slavery! Under the Geneva Convention and ALL other Democratic standards going back to the Ancient Greeks, Blair should be strung up to dangle above his wheelchair, which is EXACTLY what some dude named "Robert E. Lee" did to the saintly Freedom Fighter "John Brown" to kick off this Righteous Civil War!
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed