User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Twisting and Turning in a Sealed Room Mystery
Eventuallyequalsalways26 March 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Richard Crayell is murdered in his own house. Dr. Crabtree and the Inspector are summoned. There were 5 weekend guests at the house plus the butler. The room in which the Inspector and Dr. Crabtree inspect the evidence is overheated, and some candles are bent. The heat is from the gas logs, but the butler says Mr. Crayell rarely used them. The Inspector begins interrogating the guests. Some of the guests left the room during the evening. Some claimed they never left the room. Crayell intended on leaving all his money to one of the guests, a young man. Suddenly, a mirror over the fireplaces cracks noisily. The butler reports hearing an argument between Crayell and one of the guests. A pair of gloves is found with the initials AC, but then Crabtree indicates the gloves are his own. Mr. Crabtree discovers a door leading outside has a string on a knob while the matching door is sealed with a nail. Crabtree calls the Inspector back. He has arranged a demonstration with a pistol. Crabtree shows how Crayell could have been killed when he opened the door to allow some outside air to cool the overheated room. Then a mysterious letter is delivered to Crabtree. He is supposed to come to the garage to meet the writer of the note. While talking to a man outside the garage door, the man is shot. Claire Abbott is suddenly exposed as the killer when lightning strikes a nearby lightning rod. Then the butler delivers yet another clue in the form of a sealed box. The Inspector takes charge of the box, fearlessly opening it, and reveals it is nothing more dangerous than a music box, thus, with a humorous note bringing the viewer to the end of a 20 minute short which has so many twists and turns, it is simply enchanting.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Nice Short
Michael_Elliott29 May 2009
Week End Mystery, The (1932) ** 1/2 (out of 4) This finds Dr. Crabtree (Donald Crisp) and Inspector Carr (John Hamilton) called to an old dark house on a stormy night. There they discover the body of the home owner who was shot as he left a poker game where he had some weekend guests over. This entry in the series manages to have a couple nice sequences even though the story itself isn't anything too special. This was the second film I've seen in the series and I'm sure the original work of S.S. Van Dine had to have been popular for the studio to make them into movies but I'm also wondering how much plot had to be cut out to fit the story into a 17-minute short. What does work this time out is the atmosphere, which is pretty good. The rain effects are very noticeable as is the fake lightening but it works. Another added bonus is that Hamilton and Crisp actually bring some energy to the film and makes it move a lot better than it would have without them. Harry McNaughton is also quite good in the role of the Butler. While this movie isn't ground break or a work of art, it manages to be mildly entertaining for what it is.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed