(1954)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
I Once Watched A Pete Smith Special That Was This Long
boblipton11 May 2019
A Smith Called Pete produces and narrates this Technicolor one-reeler about sports fishing, particularly angler Ernie St. Clair, described as a 'champion fisherman.' Does this mean a champion liar? It could be.

Pete claims that Ernie uses a 6-pound line, and when he strikes a salmon, he goes swimming along, until the fish get tired. Given the near-whitewater conditions, I'd get tired way before, or the pull on the line would exceed six pounds and it would break, or I would decide that if I wanted salmon, I could buy some at the bagel store. Not Ernie! He goes swimming along for three or four miles, and when the fish gets tired and gives up, Ernie tosses them back in the water. This is what he calls fun.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Hilarious Fishing Short
alidakjones26 November 2020
This film deserves a higher rating than shown here! Quaint wordplay and wry fishing humor highlight this short film. The narrator gives an account of fishing tricks used by a young boy. Later the narrator gives running commentary on a fisherman who pursues a slippery salmon using an unconventional method.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
fittingly old fashion
SnoopyStyle12 February 2024
Two old men are telling fish tales at the docks. One of them tells the story of his grandson who caught a whole line of fish with a balloon. In another story, the boy uses his dog to catch fish while his mother calls him in. Then there is fly fisherman Ernie St. Claire who swims out into the rapids to follow a fish.

I like the Technicolor and I like the old fashion style due to the subject matter. It's fitting in its oldness including Pete Smith's narration. I'm sure that it was old fashion when it was made. It feels comfortable like an old moth-eaten sweater. I do like the kid's stories more.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
How would YOU like it if some clown jerked a hook . . .
oscaralbert11 May 2019
Warning: Spoilers
. . . through your cheek, and then dragged his dead weight behind you for THREE MILES as you bled, suffered, and struggled to escape this maniac bozo? To add in salt to injury, imagine that this entire outrageous ordeal took place in a "bad cell" dead zone, preventing you from even calling 9-1-1 for help! This is exactly what you'll be seeing taking place in a brief Real Life expose titled "FISH TALES." Miscreant "Ernie C.," as documented here, is no saint. He comes off as somewhat of a sadistic devil, torturing our Piscine American Buddies just for the hell of it. Meanie Ernie tries to salvage some semblance of Humanity by "releasing" his victim at the close of FISH TALES. But after waging an all-out war against the landlubber bully's bulbous girth for so many painfully decimating miles, this illusionary "Freedom" is bound to be short-lived for our finned friend. Ernie probably considers himself to be a "sport fisherman," in the same sense that Der Fuhrer was a "sport liquidator." However, with fiends like Ernie, who needs enemies?
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bland Smith Short
Michael_Elliott11 June 2012
Fish Tales (1954)

** (out of 4)

Bland Pete Smith short has the benefit of being in Technicolor but it offers little else. Basically we get what the title says as we hear about three different fish tales. The first deals with a boy using a balloon to catch fish. The second has a young kid tying his line to his dog's tail. The third story features Ernie St. Claire as he shows how to catch salmon and his method includes going with the fish down dangerous streams. Thankfully this short just runs for 9-minutes and even that seems a bit too long. The biggest problem is that this short just really doesn't offer anything overly interesting. Yes, the first two stories are mildly cute but that's it. The third story takes up about six-minutes of the running time and it's just a complete dud. There's nothing interesting about this person and his adventure down stream is just boring. Even Smith's narration really doesn't add any life.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed