At Suzanne's belated Christmas dinner, Andrea tries to make Jody think their relationship is turning serious, Mitch becomes insecure when his boyfriend laughs at Jody's jokes, and Billy gives Suzanne a gift that was intended for Shelley.
After learning Billy fixed her up with her boyfriend, Suzanne pretends to be crazy to nullify her divorce papers. Meanwhile, Jody reunites with his old band for a gig.
Suzanne tries to one-up a former mental patient who wrote an autobiography. Meanwhile, when Mitch learns his dad spoke to the people who publish his alumni journal, he gets irate, so Billy fires him.
Jody blackmails Mitch when he discovers he's gay. Meanwhile, Suzanne butts heads with her boyfriend's handicapped ex-wife; and Shelley ruins Billy's bachelor party.
Billy doesn't take the news very well when Mitch comes out. Meanwhile, Shelley has second thoughts about her impending nuptials; and Suzanne decides to marry herself.