"Leave It to Beaver" In the Soup (TV Episode 1961) Poster

(TV Series)

(1961)

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Iconic LITB Episode
MichaelMartinDeSapio3 September 2015
"In the Soup" is one of the best remembered and oft-cited episodes of LEAVE IT TO BEAVER. It is - dare I use the cliché - iconic. The central concept is the wackiest and most surreal in the entire series: on a dare Beaver climbs into the "soup bowl" of a roadside billboard and has to be rescued by the fire department, to the embarrassing scrutiny of a gathering crowd. Postwar consumerism, 15-minutes-of-fame celebrity, and the pop art of Andy Warhol come to mind when watching this comic tale. As Beaver sits in the bowl overwhelmed by steam, it's as if he's in one of the circles of Hell.

Interestingly, the episode comes from Season 4, a bit past the show's prime and from a period when one would have expected Beaver to be fast outgrowing these sorts of shenanigans. Beaver's "tempter" on this occasion is not his main pal Larry Mondello (who had disappeared from the show by this point) but his more peripheral buddy Whitey Whitney. Whitey was a sort of junior Eddie Haskell, and had the cute kid/wiseguy angle all figured out. It's also worth mentioning that before the episode gets around to the main plot of the soup bowl, there is a good deal of seemingly irrelevant buildup involving a party Wally is having. This has the effect of building suspense.

"In the Soup" is a metaphor for life on a number of levels. The way Beaver and Whitey's argument escalates out of nothing is a perfect spoof of many adult conflicts, on the political stage and elsewhere. The moral of the episode, brought out as usual by Ward in the concluding scene, is that we should go through life "improving ourselves, not proving ourselves" - a good lesson for any stage of life.

As LITB episodes go, this is quite an elaborate production. Imagine constructing that billboard, contriving to make steam come out of the bowl, and filming Beaver climbing into the bowl and sitting inside of it. And is that a stunt double filling in for Jerry Mathers hanging precariously from the bowl? I believe so. In any case, all this is typical of the care and artistry that went into the production of this beloved series.
29 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
THE Classic Beaver Episode
cythara7 April 2010
This episode is considered to be THE classic 'Leave it to Beaver' episode, perhaps not the best or most charming, but it was the most famous and most talked about episode for decades, representing the humor of the show. For years after the show was finally over, if the subject came up of Leave it to Beaver in conversations, the 'Soup Show' was invariably cited with, "Did you see...or...Do you remember the time Beaver fell in the soup bowl?". It is all the more strange, therefore, that it is never seen on reruns.

The entire series of 'Leave it to Beaver' stands out from all the other sitcoms that were developed during the 50s has having an authentic feel to them. Other TV shows from that time have a very contrived and artificial feel to them. 'Leave it to Beaver' always had a down to earth and next door feel to it. The only other shows to come close to achieving this natural feel even in their best years were 'Father Knows Best' and 'the Donna Reid Show', but they were always 'also rans' in comparison to 'Leave it to Beaver'.
27 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
If Lucy Had Done This, It Would Have Been Classic Comedy
richard.fuller117 December 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Like Bobby on The Brady Bunch shoving his umbrella thru the roof of the convertible, I always felt that if Lucille Ball had done this stunt, it would have been classic comedy.

Beaver is going to spend the night with his friend, Whitey, but BEFORE THEY GET TO THE WHITNEY HOUSEHOLD, Beaver and Whitey observe a billboard with a woman holding a bowl of soup and smoke coming out of the soup.

They discuss if there is really soup in the bowl or not. Beaver says there isn't, Whitey says there is.

So Beaver climbs up to look in the bowl.

As Beaver makes his way up the woman's arm, he calls down to Whitey, "boy, Whitey, you sure are a dumb kid." "Yea," Whitey mumbles to himself, "I'm a dumb kid," looking up at Beaver climbing up the sign.

When the show aired in the afternoon, I would come across this episode and wondered for the longest time how Beaver got in that bowl or whatever he was in.

I would have to catch the episode decades later to find out.

Now what made it interesting is, after Beaver had fallen into the bowl (which had no liquid in it, only dispensing smoke) and had to be rescued by the fire department, Whitey ran home to tell his parents.

Gradually other kids, from Haskell to Rutherford, and adults made their way to the billboard.

When Ward walks up, Whitey's parents were there.

What was interesting was Mr. Whitney telling Ward that it was Beaver, and that Beaver never made it to the Whitney house, thereby removing Mr. Whitney of any responsibility of Beaver's predicament, I suppose.

"Ya can't blame me, Ward. I never saw yore kid!" Still, I've always liked this one. Good dialogue with Wally and his friends as they wait for Beaver to be removed from the soup bowl.

Stands rather original as well, as I don't recall any other shows having an episode like this.
19 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Good, plausible,funny episode
ronnybee211217 November 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Older brother Wally is having his first High School party. He does not want his younger brother Beaver around to cause problems. It is decided that Beaver will stay at his old pal ''Whitey Whitney's" house on the party night. However,along the walk to Whitey's house,we have Beaver's childhood curiosity getting the better of him. After discussion with Whitey,Beaver starts climbing up a big advertising billboard that has what looks like a steaming cup of soup at the very top of the billboard-a good 25+ feet off the ground. Beaver wants to investigate how the steam is made,his pal thinks that there is real soup in the giant cup,Beaver disagrees, and they wager on it-and up he goes! All kids like to climb,so this episode is very easy to relate to. We've all done this sort of stuff to some extent,it is all part of being a kid. Fortunately,Beaver does not fall off the billboard onto the ground,but he does end-up stuck in the steaming soup cup! Naturally this situation snowballs and ends-up eclipsing older brother Wally's party...the same party that Beaver was supposed to be avoiding by sleeping over his pal's house to begin with. It is interesting to see the young party-goers dressed up so nice just for a house party,people had class for sure back then. ("I don't wanna wear a tie" just didn't work then) Anyhow,before long,the fire department arrives, and everyone from the party,(plus neighbors, passers-by,etc) are there to see the fire department 'rescue' Beaver. After Beaver gets back on the ground,he chats nonchalantly with everyone,enjoying the attention he is getting. Ward Cleaver, Beaver's father is so cool that after a short discussion he even allows Beaver to carry-on and go stay overnight with Whitey like they had planned. After Ward aggrees to let Beaver continue on to Whitey's house,Ward makes sure to mention that they will 'Talk' when he returns from Whitey's the next day. In other words,it is not over with completely, Beaver. (But Beaver knows that the worst part is past,Ward isn't that mad.) All in all a great episode. Well directed,well-written,great timing and acting,it all flows smoothly and the camera work is great also. They packed a lot into less than 30 minutes yet it never seems rushed. This really is a great episode of a great TV series,it will make the sourest sourpuss smile in spite of themselves. Watch for a good laugh!
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
My favorite and scariest Beaver episode
lorir7718 October 2019
Beaver was on every day at 10 am when I was a kid. I watched every episode sitting in my little rocking chair right in front of the TV. I remember clearly watching the soup episode when I was about 4 - 5. I adored Beaver so much that when he went in the bowl I was terrified that he was stuck there forever. My mom came into the living room and found me sobbing. Thinking I would be better off not watching she turned it off and told me to go outside. Now I was hysterical because I would never know if he got out ok. So does anyone know if he's still in the bowl?
15 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I double dog dare you. Wait. It's Beaver, a simple dare will do.
pensman14 April 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I don't know why this episode is the one so many seem to remember. It doesn't even have the right cast. This is a Larry Mondello episode if there ever was one. As we begin, Wally wants to have his first teen party at the Cleaver home. June reminisces that at Wally's last party he was twelve and the girls ended up in the living room and the boys were all in the kitchen. Yes, agrees Ward, that was when Wally was smart. Wally feels pretty good, Ward and June have promised to stay in the background, but what about Beaver. Wally gives Beaver the money to see a film because he's a good older brother. Beaver is pleased he has such a "nice" older brother; and this generosity isn't a result of Wally's party, is it? How did Beaver find out? Mom told him after Whitey invited him to sleep over that night.

The complication: on the way to Whitey's house they spot a new billboard advertising soup. This billboard has what appears to be a cup of soup with steam rising out of it. This leads to the inevitable dare about finding out if it's real soup in the cup and Beaver is once again the dupe, sucker, simpleton, plank, chump, etc. Now Beaver's in the "soup," so how is he going to be extracted? If anything, we know a) Wally's party will be disrupted, b) Everyone in town will find out, c) You can't die from embarrassment, d) Whitey won't catch any of the blame, e) Beaver will not learn anything from this escapade.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I Dare You Beaver!
sambase-3877331 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Kids love to climb. And kids love soup. So when Beaver sees a giant bowl of soup up on a billboard and the bowl of soup is steaming (yum!) he decides to climb up there. Actually, it was his annoying friend Whitey that dared him to do it. Whitey is always doing stuff like that. Whitey would tell Beaver to jump into a volcano if he thought he could get a good laugh out of it.

The giant bowl of soup is actually being "held" by the lady on the billboard, who is part poster and part wood, giving it a 3-dimensional effect. It actually looks quite cool even by today's standards. Naturally, Beaver climbs up to and then falls into the giant bowl of soup, which actually contains no soup of course because who would put a real bowl of soup up on a billboard for goodness sake. Nobody. Besides, Beaver would get scalded and die and the series would be over and Wally would be an only child and Mrs. Cleaver would be crying in her cake batter every day. And we can't have that! Nobody likes a crying beaver! I mean a crying Cleaver!

So now Beaver is stuck. Boy, is he stuck! What a place to be stuck! Up on a billboard in a giant bowl of soup!

Uh-oh, the sun is going down and it's getting dark. The light for the billboard comes on automatically, beautifully lighting up the bowl of soup and the steam coming out of it. Now Beaver's friend Whitey goes home and leaves Beaver all alone. What a friend! First he gets Beaver into this mess and then he abandons him! With friends like that.....

Meanwhile, back at the Cleaver's house, Lumpy shows up and says that there is a kid stuck in a giant bowl of soup and that it's drawing a big crowd, much like if a spaceship had suddenly landed in Times Square. So they all go over to see what the fuss is all about. Mrs. Cleaver stays behind because she's Mrs. Cleaver and that's what Mrs. Cleavers do. Besides, there is supposed to be a party happening and as of yet nobody as shown up.

Well, Mr. Cleaver and Wally and a group of people stand gawking at the giant bowl of soup with the kid in it. Still, nobody knows who the kid is. People are making wisecracks. Because that's what a kid who is stuck in a giant bowl of soup needs, he needs wisecracks. Finally, somebody calls the fire department because they have ladders and things like that. They show up and climb up and get Beaver, who is deeply embarrassed. Right then a little kid runs up and asks for Beaver's autograph, probably the funniest moment in the episode. That is a classic moment in a classic episode.

There is something wonderfully surreal and magical about this episode. The imagery is classic Americana. No wonder it's such a famous episode.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Signature LITB episode
vitoscotti27 June 2021
2 episodes earlier Beaver made a funny face in "The School Picture" . Hard to believe he's a "B" student. In sitcom life all is forgotten the next episode like it never happened.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I'm not quite sure why this is so well remembered...
AlsExGal9 March 2024
Warning: Spoilers
... as I have seen many LITB episodes as good as this one. The Hypnotist, where Eddie convinces Beaver that he has hypnotized him, comes to mind.

It starts out with Wally wanting to invite his friends over on a Friday night to "eat stuff" and listen to records. When he is granted permission, he sets out to make sure that his parents and brother are far from the proceedings. Beaver agrees to go to Whitey's house to spend the night, and so the day comes and off he goes.

On the way there, Beaver and Whitey notice a billboard advertising "Zesto Soup". It has a cardboard woman, her arm extended, holding a big bowl with steam coming out. Beaver and Whitey get into an argument of whether or not there is soup in the bowl. Whitey dares Beaver to go up and find out. Beaver takes the dare, climbs up to the bowl, looks in, and then falls in, unable to get out. There is no soup in the bowl - just steam, in case you were wondering. Whitey goes to get his father, of course denying any knowledge of why Beaver would do such a thing.

Meanwhile, darkness approaches, and Wally waits for his guests, who are all late. Lumpy eventually shows up and tells Wally that they are all over at 4th and Oak where some kid has fallen into a billboard soup bowl. Ward seems amused by this and goes over there with them, saying he can drive them back once the kid in the bowl is rescued. Once there, Ward learns from Whitey's father that the kid in the bowl is Beaver, and he ceases to be amused. A very public rescue by the fire department ensues.

Maybe this is so well remembered because it is so surreal, because it is one situation on LITB that couldn't commonly just happen. Everything else that happened on LITB is part of 50s middle class American life and is rooted in common childhood fears and memories. I don't know anybody who climbed into a bowl of soup on a billboard and needed rescuing. Of course today, if somebody were to build such a billboard, and a child were to climb into it, the parents would sue the company.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
THE INCREDIBLY FAMOUS SOUP BOWL EPISODE!
tcchelsey25 February 2024
10 Plus Stars.

Thank you to METV for running this way classic episode, probably the best of the entire series, if not for any sitcom in the early 60s. Everything clicks, and I agree with the last reviewer, LEAVE IT TO BEAVER fans always begin a conversation with this episode. In terms of tv history, it would have to be a Top 10 entry, which is saying a lot, comparable to the iconic candy factory episode on I LOVE LUCY. Heavy competition.

The fun fact about episodes like this, the story is always simple. Wally is throwing a teen party, and doesn't want Beave budding in --so Beave will spend the night at Whitey's house. BUT what happens on the way???

There's a giant (and you have admit, very interesting) billboard with a lady holding a delicious, steaming bowl of soup. Actually cup of soup production may have increased around the country because of this episode.

Whitey (Stanley Fafara) kind of, sort of challenges Beave to climb all the way up there to see if it's REAL? Even as a kid, I thought that was an outrageous thing to do... But Beaver does the deed and gets stuck as stuck can be. The proverbial question; WHY is it always Beave?

Can you believe it, and the scene is realistically done. Production notes indicate the episode was the most expensive to produce, about $40,000, which would be about 412,000 dollars today. Keep in mind, an average tv episode (in 2024) costs over a million dollars to make, giving you an idea of Hollywood inflation! They actually got away cheap.

Whitey, who generally played a cool friend, shows another side of himself, like Larry Mondello. Beave looks down at him from the billboard and snaps, "There's nothing in here, you're a dumb kid!" Whitey comes back with a priceless smirk and replies, "Yaaaa. I'm a dumb kid...!" What a laugh out loud scene. Thank you to Norman Abbott, nephew of comedian Bud Abbott, who directed a ton of hit sitcoms, such as SANFORD AND SON.

Veteran actor Harry Holcombe plays Mr. Whitney, who played a judge on many episodes of PERRY MASON. A super trivia note about actress Lenore Kingston who plays Whitey's mom. She was the laughing lady in Jim Backus' (GILLIGANS ISLAND) famous gag record called "Delicious" released in 1958. Listen for it, it's funny.

A gotsta' see from start to finish, and watch Ward marvel at the bizarro circumstances. Also featuring a lot of extra actors (in the street below), with a good shot of one of Universal's street sets as the camera pulls back. A real gem, and we still love Whitey.

Remember, the magic word is ZESTO.

SEASON 4 EPISODE 32 remastered. Get the box set for this.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed