"Perry Mason" The Case of the Credulous Quarry (TV Episode 1960) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Mystery that leads to good courtroom drama
kfo949413 June 2012
Attorney Everett Dorrell represented Dick Hammond in a lawsuit in an accident involving his family. However the settlement was less than expected and money was need for surgery for Dick's mother. Everett Dorrell agrees to loan Dick some money for the surgery and they agree to meet that evening.

While Everett was waiting for Dick Hammond, he receives a call that his ex-girlfriend, Helen Austin, is about to commit suicide so he gets in his car to go see her. But when he starts out of his driveway, he runs over Helen Austin just as Dick Everett is pulling up to the house. The two decide that Dick Hammond will dispose of the body since Mr Dorrell is giving him $15,000 for his mother's surgery. And so Dick goes out and places the body along the roadside and calls the police.

The next morning Dick Hammond awakes to the fire department outside his house. His garage had been set afire and when the fireman open the garage Everett Dorrell's car (the one that hit Helen) is inside his garage. Dick knows he is getting 'set-up' so he consults Perry for advise.

While Perry investigates, it seems that Lt Tragg finds more evidence that Dick Hammond was the murderer. And people that Dick thought was friends begin to turn on him. This will lead to dramatic courtroom scene where people that have secrets will be in interrogated until Perry finds the truth concerning the entire situation.

This episode has some of the best courtroom scenes that we have seen in some time. Perry is at the top of his game as he finds hole after hole in each person's testimony. A good watch for any mystery fan.

NOTE- Two things which stands out in this episode- This episode was to be seen in season three before Talman was fired as we get the season three opening as we see head-shots of Paul, Della, Hamilton Burger and Lt Tragg. Also, be prepared for the driveway scene. When Everett hits Helen, it comes across as rather shocking for 1960 TV.
29 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Burger Tries To Short Circuit Mason
DKosty12326 December 2009
Warning: Spoilers
This episode is stronger than most because it show cases Burr as Mason in the court room. It has a crooked lawyer, a murder, bribes, and leaves a couple of folks still in trouble with the law at the end including Mason's client.

The real strength is in the court room sequence where Burger unexpectedly rests the prosecution early & forces Mason to call 4 witnesses to present a defense of his client. Then he gets the dramatic courtroom confession from the murderer. Masons cross-examination here is top notch.

Hamilton Burger (William Talman) is good here too trying to short circuit Mason in the court room & then watching in amazement when Mason produces a murderer out of the examinations.
19 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
More disorienting than a funhouse mirror...
AlsExGal2 January 2023
... because you begin to wonder, what did I really see?

Richard Hammond goes to his attorney, Everett Dorrell, to see if he can get fifteen thousand dollars from his trust. He cannot. He needs the money for medical care for his mother, who was made an invalid from a car accident two years before. Dorrell offers to loan Hammond the money and Hammond accepts. They agree to meet that night at Dorrell's house where he will give Hammond the money.

When Hammond comes up Dorrell's drive that night, he sees Hammond has accidentally hit an old girlfriend who ran in front of his car and is dead. To keep Dorrell free from scandal, Hammond says he will take the girl's body and place it on the street across town, then call the police and say he found her. He does this.

Later that night his garage door is ablaze, and the firemen who put out the fire claim that he called them - he did not. Inside the garage nothing is damaged, but something new has been added. That something new is the car that actually ran over the girl, parked next to his. Then later the next day he is confronted by the dead girl's aunt who says that she knows he has her niece's fifteen thousand dollars. So what goes on here? Watch and find out. It turns out that all of the principals are more connected than you'd think as Mason defends Hammond against the charge of murdering the girl.

What is different and amusing is the dead girl's smirking aunt who really wants that fifteen thousand dollars. As she tells Perry, if she can figure out where the fifteen thousand came from, maybe she can figure out how to get another.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Best jump scare
barbjryan8 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Two things that jump out at me in this episode (pun intended) is one, it has the best jump scare, not typical in this show. When the body is thrown out in front of the car, it literally made me jump. Second, the first conversation with the Aunt and Mason is a hoot. Auntie is one freaky dame.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Incredulous
darbski11 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** I'm giving it a 10 because of the courtroom interplay. The incredulous part is the whole set up itself. The body, the driveway, no lights, etc. etc. all add up to just too much to sort it out and care about Perry's client or the original case. One thing that I liked was the old bat that thought she was going to cash in, and getting shut out, and shut up. Della is beautiful, of course, and the acting, generally, is very good, but this one should have been cleaned up on the writer's table before releasing it as a screenplay, I think.
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Incompetence
calvinboldjm9 February 2024
I love watching Mason episodes, and this one was terrific, especially the courtroom examinations and crosses. There was one plot inconsistency, where the murder victim's husband said under testimony that he didn't know who the passenger was in his wife's car, but toward the end Perry said that the husband had threatened to tell the guy's wife. If true, he would not have needed his wife for the blackmail even earlier. Anyway, what I'm always amazed with is how incompetent the DA and his main detective are. Tragg consistently comes across as smug and sarcastic as he whips out his murder warrants, and then goes down in flames as usual. He seemed particularly smug in this episode. And Burger, the Washington Generals of the courtroom, was particularly petulent and peevish in the courtroom, which as referenced above showcased some of the best back-and-forth of the entire series. Burger was almost to the point of throwing down his pencil, stomping his feet and storming out of the courtroom. In real life, these two would be jobless.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Pretty Obtuse
Hitchcoc11 January 2022
The whole plot revolves around a hit and run that would require incredible precision to pull off. It also makes the sad situation for a man who is in need of help being promised money and then being betrayed by a good friend because of a compromising position. But there are too many variables here and it makes it unsatisfying as it plays out.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Not sure what happened
bkoganbing29 August 2019
Maybe because I was ill viewing this and couldn't follow the plot, but this one had me reaching.

We never see the victim in this case but apparently she was greedy, grasping female. All we see is that this woman comes from out of nowhere and gets hit by John Conwell's car.

Perry Mason gets him off a vehicular homicide charge, but then he's charged with murder so Raymond Burr is back in court.

I'm no lawyer, but that sounds like double jeopardy. Still Burr does it the hard way and finds the real murderer.

Not well thought out.
6 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
I want my Money !
kapelusznik186 February 2015
Warning: Spoilers
****SPOILERS**** Utterly ridicules Perry Mason,Raymond Burr, episode with the star of the show hit and run and later murder victim Helen Austin not even being in the shows ending credits! It was Helen who after calling her ex-lover lawyer Everett Dorrell, Russell Arms, and threaten to commit suicide ends up getting hit by his car, with its front lights off, as he was on his way trying to stop her from doing it! It's Dorrell's good friend and client Richard Hammond, John Conwell, who just happens to show up and with Dorrell giving him $15,000.00 who just happened to have the cash on him agrees to cover up the incident! For all his trouble Hammond is later arrested for Helen's death by someone planting evidence, including the damaged hit and run car, in his garage!

The big surprise comes in that it was Dorrell was won a damage suit in a hit and run accident a year ago where his good friend and client Hammond's mom was gravely injured and sister killed! And as Perry soon find out it was the person behind the wheel who was being blackmailed by Helen for as much as $2,000.00, that about $15,000.00 in 2015 dollars, a month to keep her mouth shut about it! Chould that person have been behind Helen's death or murder?

****SPOILERS**** Things get a bit fuzzy when the late Helen Austin's husband Alexander Hill played by Walter Reed, not the guy who cured yellow fever, pops up at Hammond's trial not as a witness but an interested observe. Perry after exhausting all those suspected in Helen's death zero's in on the upright and pillar of the community Marvin Clartidge, Hayworth,who's law-firm Dorrell works for and who's daughter Barbara ,Nan Peterson, he's engaged to. It's at the trail that Perry without as much as breaking a sweat gets Helen's killer to brake down and confess his crime. Not by cross examining him but by the killer or the actor who played him so sick and tired of having to sit through this entire atrocity, lame Perry Mason episode, in him just having about enough and finally putting, by confessing his guilt, an end to it all!
5 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed