"Route 66" Who in His Right Mind Needs a Nice Girl (TV Episode 1964) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Intriguing relationship between the two romantic leads.
lrrap11 June 2020
The relationship between Lee Philips and Lois Smith is complex and intriguing; it's well-written, well-directed, and very well acted---especially the scene in the back room of the library where Lee returns from his "Bon Voyage" outing with Linc n' Tod.

I've always liked Lee Phillips, who portrayed calm, tough and "cool" characters convincingly... a difficult thing to pull off. There's something special about his confidence and cockiness, with flashes of wit and sarcasm, that keeps me involved in what he's doing, and the scene I mentioned above is a great example.

The ultimate resolution of this show was not particularly satisfying...as if the author and director had to end things in a neat and tidy way to get to the final credits.Also, I'd say we have a case of justifiable homicide in the opening scene; those two boorish jerks on the boat were BEYOND obnoxious. No one could blame Lee for dumping them overboard.

Unfortunately, the tendency of the two "sister productions"-- Route 66 and Naked City--to play most of the local, secondary characters as cartoon-y CARICATURES continues to undermine the dramatic quality of these shows. The old lady in the opening is OK, but Elizabeth McRae's air-head, sex-kitten thing is SO overdone that it's barely watchable. It definitely detracts from the tone of the drama.

The Linc = good,/compassionate guy and Tod = impatient/boorish guy routine has, by this point in the 4th season, become predictable and ineffective. But with only a few more episodes to go, there's no point in complaining. And even though I like Glenn Corbett, Maharis was a better, more versatile actor, who could play EITHER role-- kind/compassionate OR impatient/boorish--- equally well.

ALSO- the scene with Lee Philips driving the Corvette on the beach gave Nelson Riddle a brief opportunity to "open up" in his best free-wheeling, swingin', 60's musical idiom.

LR
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A LOT OF MEN WOULD HAVE LIKED TO MEET A "NICE GIRL"
larryanderson25 May 2020
The title suggests that no one wants to meet a NICE GIRL like the librarian. That isn't true as I would have liked to meet someone like her, especially back in the 1960s. I went to Daytona Beach for the first time in 1966 and fell in love with the place. I have been back there many, many times since. In this story the girl falls for an insane criminal which will never work out for her, as a snake is a snake and can't be anything else. Too bad she didn't meet a nice guy instead. This episode was filmed in Daytona Beach Florida but they never even mention the world famous Speedway. The story should have seen the guys working on a pit crew or in a speed garage or something Racing related. Great acting by all.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Interesting Insight into the True Life Charlie Starkweather Case
rwint161113 October 2008
Slow paced episode dealing with a killer (Phillips) who gets involved with a lonely and shy librarian (Smith).

In some ways this episode has its moments especially with regards to the theme. The characters resemble the true life Charlie Starkweather affair where a shy teenage girl fell in love with a spree killer in 1950's Nebraska. It offers some good insights as to why an otherwise 'nice' girl would be attracted to a 'bad' boy. It shows how the woman is so lonely and bored with her existence that she reaches out to this otherwise dangerous man because she finds him 'sick and helpless' and someone who she can 'save' with her love as well as finding him a much needed diversion to her stagnate life. The role of the killer also is created with some insight as he shown as someone with a very low self-esteem, lack of direction, and full of bitterness and self-loathing. This is a lot different and more in depth portrayal of a killer than what you usually see in most other movies and TV shows.

However in the end the show becomes very talky and in need of a lot more action and plot twists. The best part comes at the very beginning where the killer is driving a motorboat out on the lake and swings it around at such a reckless speed that it knocks the other occupants off the boat where they then drown. However even this has some problems. One of which is the fact that it is never explained why he did this. Was he just some psychotic who did it for fun? Or did he have some past grievance with this couple and did it for revenge? None of this is explained, but probably should have been. Of course with the incredibly annoying way that the couple is seen singing an already incredibly annoying song as the show opens one could probably not blame the killer for knocking them off the boat as anyone might consider it.

This episode does feature both Phillips and Smith giving some fine performances. Both had appeared in earlier episodes, but seem to give their best work here. This episode also features the rare scene where someone else besides Tod ends up driving the Corvette. It occurs when Tod hands the wheel over to Phillips who promptly drives the car along the crashing waves of the ocean and skims the water over the car, which is kind of cool to watch.

Grade: C +
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/7/64 "Who in His Right Mind Needs a Nice Girl"
schappe11 March 2016
Lee Philiips returns, this time as a murderer on the lam, (no he didn't kill his wife: he dumped an aged couple overboard after agreeing to take them on a motor boat trip and they drown). He holes up in, of all things, a mobile library annex run by Lois Smith, (making her third appearance in the series), a lonely, impressionable librarian. The boys show up and Linc senses something is wrong and decides to hang around. Tod, as usual is detached and doesn't want to get involved. Phillips romances the impressionable Smith, (although he seems to see the possibilities of another life with her), and convinces her to help him out. Linc tries to convince her to break away from him. The police eventually catch up and Phillips is killed in a shoot- out. She's back to her lonely life.

Sad and dramatic but not very credible.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Two Not So Right Minds Chance Meet
AudioFileZ13 January 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Who In His Right Mind Needs a Nice Giri is posited as an example when a conniving con meets a person he can manipulate. Tod and Linc are still in the Daytona Beach area and Linc is frequenting the local library, perhaps to read, but more likely to steal moments with a winsome librarian. Problem is a youthful drifter who has just caused two deaths by his actions drops at the library in need of a con-game to get out of town.

Another completely dark Route 66 episode with only small amounts of travelogue respite, still Who In His Right Mind, etc. is somewhat compelling in its strangeness. Perhaps this is due to the performances turned in by two already veteran TV talents. Lois Smith guest stars as the naive young and lonesome librarian Lucy, and Lee Phillips as the drifter Joe. Both are top-notch TV actors and they bring some urgency to the weakly fleshed out story. Basically, as Joe runs from his crime he finds Lucy to be the perfect patsy to provide his bankroll to leave town. Linc observes the strange interaction of the two in the library and as his usual "save-the-day" behavior gets involved. Tod, as is usual too, is conscripted. The two make it a point to give Joe the obligatory ride out of town and in the process have, to say the least, a strange interaction of their own.

Tod and Linc can't save Lucy from her own naiveté, but they accompany her as her protector. In the end Lucy looses her savings and learns a hard lesson in spontaneity. A strange episode thus ends with a kind of head-scratching open ending.

While there may be some bigger issues alluded to here, the end effect is rather questionable. Route 66 is floundering in it's fourth season and it shows. One can imagine it, as a series, still losing viewers as this stuff really isn't endearing entertainment. Still, there is something in the interaction of our two road warriors as they go about their travels doing good. Not a must see unless you want to check out the performances of Lois Smith and Lee Phillips, two actors with some of the longest TV resumes extant.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed