"Doctor Who" The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Four (TV Episode 1986) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
"Wake me when it's finished..." Uninspiring ending to The Mysterious Planet segment.
poolandrews15 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Doctor Who: The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Four starts as Valeyard (Michael Jayston) begins to wrap his case up, the Matrix continues to play out the events on Ravolox as the Doctor (Colin Baker) tries to prevent a black light explosion which could theoretically destroy the galaxy but at the very least will destroy Ravolox & it's inhabitants. The evidence seems to vindicate the Doctor but the Valeyard says he still has evidence that will surely condemn him to death...

Episode 4 from season 23 this Doctor Who adventure originally aired here in the UK during September 1986, directed by Nicholas Mallett this episode was the fourth & final part of The Mysterious Planet segment of The Trial of a Time Lord which spanned the whole season. The scripts for these opening four episodes were by Robert Holmes & feels like a rather routine & average Doctor Who story with the narrative cutting back to the court room trial scenes every so often, personally I didn't think it was anything overly special. The character's weren't great, there wasn't much incident to get excited about, the sci-fi elements are unimaginative & as a whole the story is uninspiring. The main villain Drathro just isn't menacing enough for me, he doesn't seem evil enough & isn't so much defeated as just falls over & dies. The ending wasn't great either with lots of talking which doesn't go anywhere. There's some humour in The Mysterious Planet, Dibber was the comedy relief, the way the Doctor behaves in the court room is amusing & there's a slap stick moment where someone gets a face full of green slime.

This has been quite a well made serial & there isn't too much to complain about apart from some awful looking red laser beams. Apart from the wonderful opening shot from Part 1 of the space station Drathro the robot is probably the most impressive aspect of the production & it must have been a nightmare for the poor guy stuck inside it! There hasn't been anything scary in this so far, it's more of a morality tale dressed in sci-fi clothing.

The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Four of The Mysterious Planet is alright, as a four part story in it's own right it's not much better than average. The next instalment of The Trial of a Time Lord starts another mini four part story called Mindwarp.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
An improvement, but still a bit disjointed.
Sleepin_Dragon27 December 2019
The Doctor offers help to Drathro, meanwhile the temperamental Robot wants all organic life to be dealt with. The Valeyard continues in pursuit of The Doctor in the courtroom.

I must applaud Colin for his performance here, he does very well with the script he's given, he's passionate, energetic, sincere, and really gives his all, sadly the script is weak. I have liked both Glitz and Dibber, lots of fun, and actually quite devious.

This has some interesting moments, who are The Sleepers? Why have segments been redacted, and who's behind it?

It's an improved episode over the last few, it just should have been a whole lot better. 6/10
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The Trial of a Time Lord: Part Four
Prismark1012 April 2019
Well Queen Katryca and her tribesmen arrive at the underground bunker and decide to confront the robot Drathro, the Immortal one. Obviously Drathro was not a fan of Joan Sim's acting. I blame the lines she was given, sorry Robert Holmes.

The Doctor tries to get Drathro to spare the humans and also he tells the robot that he will repair the black light converter. The Doctor fears that if it explodes it will have disastrous consequences. Glitz and Dibber helped out in dealing with the Immortal One.

Of course by the end, The Doctor has a smug satisfied look. He has freed the humans from Drathro and prevented the black light converter from exploding.

It all makes the Valeyard's case look weak. That is the problem with the trial concept. The Valeyard accuses him of interference and causing violence and mayhem wherever he goes.

As Doctor Who fans will know. The second Doctor was charged with all this back in The War Games. The third Doctor was forgiven by the High Council of the Time Lords. Here the Doctor has ultimately helped the situation and there is still the mystery of how Earth ended up in the wrong place.

The Valeyard argues there is more evidence to present which leads to the next adventure.

Overall the story is better than I remembered from its broadcast back in 1986. That is not saying much, I just remembered the whole thing being dreadful. Now it is just less dreadful. The trial scenes just look so badly directed, almost inert and stagy.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed