"Leave It to Beaver" The Merchant Marine (TV Episode 1962) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Eddie? Maybe. Clarence? A stretch. Wally? No way period.
pensman10 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Wally is in a bit of trouble with Ward. He was very late in getting home and didn't call to tell either parent. Wally says he did try but the line was busy. Maybe a good excuse, but Ward wasn't buying it. Wally finds himself the recipient of a stern lecture.

A few days later day June finds a letter addressed to Wally. It's a booklet for the Merchant Marine. June suspects Wally is planning on running away because of the harsh lecture Ward gave him. Even Ward is buying in. Perhaps they should be more considerate of Wally and his feelings. They try to sound him out at dinner, but aren't having much success. And it's for a good reason, the envelope for the Merchant Marine was for Lumpy. Lumpy is angry with his dad for taking away his car keys. Wally suggests instead of running away Lumpy try talking with his dad. Lumpy says he tried but then he got angry and ran upstairs and locked himself in his room. Lumpy feels by running away he will show his dad what a grown man he is.

When a letter of application for the Merchant Marine arrives at home, June calls Ward at work. Fred overhears Ward talking with June. If Wally is having problems, it's because Ward doesn't have the relationship with Wally that Fred has with his Clarence. If nothing else, Fred claims, is that he knows his boy.

But when Lumpy gets the application he claims he is going to fill it out. At home, Ward confronts Wally, but Wally explains it's all for Lumpy. Wally says he has been doing his best to convince Lumpy his idea of running away is stupid. Wally says Lumpy isn't as lucky both he and the Beaver are in having a guy like Ward for their father. Wally says he knows he can always talk with his dad, Lumpy doesn't have that relationship with his dad.

Ward says if Wally can't convince Lumpy then Ward will have to speak with Fred. Now things are spiraling out of control. Beaver told just about everyone that Wally was running away. Even Mary Ellen calls Wally and asks if she can keep his sweater to remember him by, even if they did break-up. Wally tells her it's fine, she can keep the sweater. Ward decides he has to call Fred, but Fred comes over to straighten Wally out. He emphasizes to Wally and Ward the wonderful relationship he has with Clarence. Lumpy uses the opportunity to get his car keys back. Problem solved, Lumpy hands Wally the application so Wally can toss it.

Ward at least is happy, he knows he has a solid relationship with his boys. But what about Fred? He's always the last to know. I guess we will have to accept this episode as one that warns of possible future problems with Clarence and his daddy. But how was it even possible that Ward and June to believe Wally would run away? Are there dark secrets in the Cleaver household? Nah. Even I couldn't believe that. But Wally does have a problem: How to get his sweater back from Mary Ellen.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Fred & Lumpy revive a tired series
vitoscotti26 July 2021
Fred's part was great. Lumpy's good but he's had better. The 2 perked up the rudderless series in season 5. Finally a fresh script. The episodes star was always obnoxious Fred. Ward is a saint how he handles Fred.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
At first the audience is in the dark for a change!
AlsExGal23 March 2024
Ward gives Wally a stern talking to for coming home two hours late and not even calling. Wally is annoyed that he tried to call, the line was busy, and that his dad thought he should have continued to try calling and yelled at him anyways.

The following week the Cleaver household suddenly starts getting mail from the Merchant Marine. Ward and June fear they went too far with Wally over his coming home a little late and that now he's planning to go to sea! Usually the audience knows what is really going on and watches on amused as Ward and June try to figure out what is going on, but not this time.

The truth is revealed when Lumpy comes over and talks to Wally. It is Lumpy who plans on joining the Merchant Marine because he feels like his father is against him, and the way Fred Rutherford talks to him that is not hard to understand. Lumpy has been having all of the information and application material sent to Wally's house so that his parents won't see it. Ward and Wally talk matters out and Ward learns the truth, but how to either get Lumpy to change his mind or tell Fred the truth, knowing Lumpy's lack of maturity and Fred's obnoxious know-it-all personality. Watch and find out.

Apparently in 1960 it was legal for a minor who had reached the age of 17 to join the Merchant Marine without parental consent, so there was a legitimate concern here that Lumpy might just go through with his plan with no parent being able to stand in his way.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Life with Lumpy
MichaelMartinDeSapio27 October 2015
This is one of the few LITB episodes that center on Lumpy Rutherford; the only others that come to mind are "Lumpy's Scholarship" and a couple of early episodes in which Lumpy was a bully.

Angry with his dad, Lumpy has decided to quit school and join the Merchant Marines. Only thing is, he has had letters and pamphlets from the Marines forwarded to Wally's address so that his dad won't suspect anything. Now, when June discovers these communiqués she is sure that a recent reprimand from Ward has driven Wally to leave home.

Of all the regular LITB characters, Lumpy has always been the most difficult for me to like, but this episode succeeds in humanizing him - or at least making us feel pity for him. The relationship he enjoys with his father Fred Rutherford is dysfunctional, to put it mildly. Blowhard Fred likes to pretend he is the perfect up-to-date progressive father, full of the latest pop psychology. The reality is quite different, as we learn here: in this family the father doesn't know what the son is up to. You might say that Lumpy and Fred live in a mutually-fed world of delusion.

The character of Lumpy was memorably fleshed out (as it were) by the late Frank Bank. He played the role as a classic "follower" with little mind of his own, an oafish "second banana" to Eddie Haskell, with always just a touch of effeminate dopeyness ("Yes, Daddy!") that took away any menacing edge the character might have had.

On another note, I continually wonder why people call LITB a "simplistic" show. Nothing could be further from the truth. This episode has enough irony and emotional complexity for a one-act stage play, with camera work and acting that express the relationships among the characters. It's the small details that made this series great. Just one example: in the closing scene, Ward June and Beaver stand framed in the doorway watching Lumpy and Fred depart; but instead of a symmetrical arrangement, Beaver stands in front of Ward, almost obscuring him: the perfect visual metaphor of a son growing into manhood and taking the place of his father. Indeed, this is a prominent theme of the episode: at one point when Wally is scolding Lumpy for his behavior, Lumpy tells Wally that he sounds just like his father.

Just one example how artful a series LITB was.
17 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
MARINES, LETS GO!
tcchelsey20 March 2024
This is an excellent family episode, actually a tale of two families. The Cleavers and the Rutherfords.

And without fail, another insightful story (with a comedy slant) by Dick Conway.

Lumpy is having problems at home and wants to join the Merchant Marine. However... all the related material is sent to the Cleaver's house so old Fred Rutherford won't catch on to what his son is up to.

Murphy's Law in full swing here. June naturally finds the paperwork and believes it's Wally who is going to join the US Marines! Don't you love this, but the two to watch here is definitely Lumpy and Fred, so well played by Richard Deacon. With a father like that, you couldn't really blame Lump for resorting to some desperate measures.

Another super episode where Ward --without fail -- shows he's a darn good father. Also to note, Frank Bank, as Lumpy, gets a larger role for a change of pace and with more depth, again thanks to Dick Conway who generally did more with Eddie Haskell's character. A thoughtful touch, and all us kids loved that.

From SEASON 5 EPISODE 30 remastered.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A Secret Between Wally And Lumpy
StrictlyConfidential23 December 2020
Just like Eddie Haskell, Gilbert Bates, and Richard Rickover, Clarence Rutherford (aka. "Lumpy") was yet another character from TV's "Leave It To Beaver" who I just couldn't warm up to.

So, when Lumpy decided to join the Merchant Marines I couldn't be more pleased with the thought that I'd never have to see his dumb face ever again.

But, unfortunately, this episode's storyline took an unwelcome twist that completely turned Lumpy's plans to join the navy around.
3 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed