User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
It has some plot holes for sure
AlsExGal13 July 2023
The titular Martin Kane, P. I. is played by William Gargan. I mention that because the role went to a variety of actors over the five years of its run.

The retrial of a man previously convicted of robbing a grocery store and killing the wife of the owner is in progress when a surprise witness appears and says that he committed the robbery and the murder, not the accused. The catch is that the surprise witness is under sentence of death for a gangland killing, scheduled for execution in two weeks. When the D. A. steps forward to cross examine him, the witness pulls out a gun and kills the D. A. The witness then says that the defense attorney slipped him the gun and that, being condemned to death, there is nothing that can be done to him. The defense attorney denies any involvement and Martin Kane is on the case.

This one turned out to be rather involved to the point that, when the responsible parties are revealed, I went - WHO?? - and had to play back earlier portions of the episode to see just who it was being talked about. I can just imagine how confused the people gathered around their flickering cathode ray tubes would have been in 1951 with no means to rewind anything.

Humorous stuff I noticed - so many close-ups so that there is no need for fancy art design and the sets can be dressed cheaply. Also, William Garghan as Kane is always wearing that trench coat. I wonder if he wears it to the beach?

The one set that the producers did bother to dress - The one in the tobacco shop where, for some reason, all of the principal players gather to discuss clues and plot developments. Of course it is because the show's sponsor is a tobacco company! The police are sure to save on pensions by encouraging all of that smoking in their ranks!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Interesting though not particularly good example of early live television
fredcdobbs526 September 2021
A District Attorney is questioning a witness in a murder trial when the witness--a convicted murderer awaiting execution--suddenly pulls out a gun and kills the DA. Private investigator Martin Kane is asked to solve the mystery and find out who gave the killer the gun and why he or she wanted the DA dead.

This series was shot live on videotape, and mistakes such as flubbed lines--of which there are quite a few--got left in, as well as some hilariously blatant product placement spots for the show's sponsor, a tobacco company.

The show has the low-rent look of a '40s cheapjack effort from PRC, and the acting and the writing are on a par with that, although Frank DeKova--better known as Chief Wild Eagle from the '60s comedy series "F Troop"--injects a little life into the boring proceedings as the DA's killer.

Interesting as an example of the early days of television, but taken by itself, it's not much.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed