Fagara (2019) Poster

(2019)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A well-crafted gem
ctowyi13 September 2019
There's hope for Hong Kong's cinema yet. Fagara passed our acid test with flying colours - throughout the 30-minute journey home, the missus and I were discussing the movie animatedly, drawing on parallels with our lives and little nuggets of nuances continued to surface. This is a gem and truly the first good film from Hong Kong this year that isn't an action genre flick.

The story pivots and pirouettes on Acacia (Sammi Cheng), a travel agent in Hong Kong who discovers she has two half-sisters after her estranged father Ha Leung (Kenny Bee) suddenly dies. One is Branch (Megan Lai), an androgynous professional snooker player in Taiwan, and the other is fashionista v-blogger Cherry (Li Xiaofeng), living in China. They meet at their father's funeral and a journey of self-discovery ensues.

I was pleasantly surprised by the opening scene which features a telephone conversation between a world weary looking Sammi Cheng and a two-timing customer. It wasn't what was said that confounded me; it was the fact that the entire conversation was in Cantonese that put a smile on my face. Finally, a Hong Kong movie that was left unmolested by the MDA (the Media Development Authority) and the Cantonese language sounded like music to my ears. Frankly, my government's insistence on dubbing all films and programmes that come from Hong Kong to mandarin has outlived its objectives. It's high time to leave these films untouched.

Hong Kong writer-director Heiward Mak's last mainstream hit was Love in a Puff (2010), a quirky look at modern romance, which she co-wrote. With Fagara, she has ascended a new level. With a drama about three sisters coming together after the sudden death of their father from three different mothers, it wouldn't be out of place for it to be emotionally coercive, but Mak demonstrates sublime restraint and astute instincts to steer the narrative in a different direction.

Fagara doesn't rush out of the blocks to tell its heartfelt story. Mak allows the newly-acquainted half-sisters to live and breathe, filling the scenes they are in with authenticity and authority. These are not soft and malleable women; they are their own women, owing no explanations for the paths they have chosen in life, giving the movie a wonderful freshness, relevance and clarity.

There is a focus on character detail, with the doling out of exposition and backstory happening throughout the course of the movie in luminous flashbacks. There are no weak characters here and the casting is exquisite. Sammi Cheng, without a smidgen of glamour, does the heavy lifting, and she is a revelation. Her weariness is palpable and her vulnerability permeates her entire being. Megan Lai and Li Xiaofeng fill their scenes with humility and humanism too. Using these well-drawn characters in their own spheres, Mak is making a point with the modern women who owe no one for the choices they make in life.

The writing is peppered with many life-affirming gems and most of the time they are delivered by Richie Jen and Andy Lau cameos. There is also much humour rendered by a cockroach and the kitchen.

Fagara is a well-crafted story of three half-sisters looking back into their painful pasts in order to venture forward into their futures with revitalised hope. It is filled with many nuances and it allows you the time to tease out its narrative subtleties on your own. Instead of ramming into your solar plexus, it gracefully touches you with its strong flavours and deep reds and browns. The whole thing actually feels like a Hirokazu Kore-eda meditation on the splintered family, and I mention Kore-eda's name with deep respect for Heiward Mak's craft.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A compelling story that this city needs.
v6125 September 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This is a story about coping with hurt, of dealing with relationships and about self-healing.

The main storyline talks about a father with three daughters, each with different mothers and lives separately in Hong Kong, Taiwan and China. The eldest sister, Acacia (played by Sammi Cheng), lives in Hong Kong and is struggling to start her own life after breaking up with her ex-fiance. She found out about the other two sisters after her father's death, and have struggled with running her father's hotpot shop. Her storyline explore how one should deal with hurting moments in the past. Through taking over her father's hotpot shop and building a relationship with her two sisters, she is able to self-recover and reconcile with herself. The last scene where she shouts to her deceased father is especially heartbreaking. Through her journey of exploring the differences between the two generations, as well as to understand her father, she was able to cope with her past hatred of her father, and recover from the sudden loss of her father.

The second eldest sister, Branch (played by Megan Lai), is a professional pool player struggling to make a living, and not knowing how to get along with her mother. She is a determined and freedom-loving individual living in Taiwan, but she always felt her efforts in playing pool is not appreciated by her mother.

The youngest sister, Cherry (played by Li Xiaofeng) is a fashion streamer living in China. Having been abandoned by both her father and mother, she lives with her grandmother who always urge her to get married. Her storyline deals with the perplexion of facing an unknown future.

From the director's sharing, the three sisters each represent facing the past, the present, and the future. They are also born in 70s, 80s and 90s respectively.

The time they spent living together and running the hotpot shop, is a like a shelter where they can pull away from their problems, be a better self and return back to their lives respectively.

Few lines that resonate deeply with Hong Kong viewers, is when Blanche got drunk and says, "If I worked really hard, but I still can't win, what should I do? If we work really hard, but the world still does not get any better, what should we do?" (widespread due to a trailer for Hong Kong Film Awards). Another line is "If you have worked hard before in your life, you will not say it does not matter."

As an individual facing such a cruel and unjust world, perhaps as the director shared, we should our best not to become an evil person. We may need time to heal from the deep trauma and wound in our society, but we will endure this and rise up again stronger than before.

This film was released at the worst of times, but also at the best of times.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A movie that seems to be telling the story of a hotpot restaurant, but actually contains a great political aspiration.
SidSea14 September 2019
(1) For the first time I experienced that, all of the audienced didn't even stand up until the end of the film fully played. It seems that all of the audiences are hongkonger except me. (2) The audience sitting in front of me cried, they seems to be a family of three. (3) I wish all compatriots on both sides of the Taiwan Strait and in four places a happy Mid-Autumn Festival.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Family, hatred to dad for not being a true dad, reunion
shibal-0090221 May 2020
Not too bad movie, China 🇨🇳 + Taiwan 🇹🇼 + hk A lot of famous supporting actors Storyline of united family after her dad passed away Good acting by hk actors 👍
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
How to mend a broken heart
madbird-6124329 May 2021
This is more or less a standard story on how a woman come to term with his father, who has form families with two other women. This let me think of Little big women, depicting the the meeting of the original and second wife upon the funeral of the husband. The latter is more attractive me. It may be because o the Taiwan custom which is newer to me,or for some other reasons that is unexplainable. Or I simply like female director.

The present movie is slow and dull. It always show scenes that how the father love his restaurant workers, how he helps Sammy Cheng with the school dictation, how he follow the match of his Taiwan daughter. All are praising his dad. I just cannot figure out how Sammy could forgive his father with this little trivial things. His dad is really a Xxxx that cannot be forgiven.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A slow but touching one
ryanmo-351783 April 2021
Although the movie is slow, but the scenes that the two accidental sisters were not strange. Really like the scene that her father really loved her indeed, and even cried when she said she misses him. We should all value others when they are around.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Fills the tummy and heart
wickedmikehampton16 December 2020
'Fagara' would've been stronger without the occasional over-acting but it pulled heartstrings and delivered smiles the way a melodrama should.

Three adult sisters with a father in common, two from Taiwan and one from Hong Kong, get to know each other when he dies.

Because the colour of warmth is food, the setting is his small restaurant that's famous for a hotpot soup whose recipe they can't quite figure out.

My biggest takeaway is thousands of years of Asian culture outpaces anything my South Africa has to offer. I'm damn hungry now. I'm literally salivating as I think of those bubbling frying pans on the customers tables. I've conveniently excluded the fact that all those spices in a small room would unite with my asthma to kill me. I'll give my life for a happy tongue. I'll get famous as the Kamikaze Tummy.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed