In Your Absence (2008) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
An unusual and touching film.
Uneken13 October 2008
The film "En tu Ausencia" is the debut of composer/filmmaker Iván Noel. I have personally witnessed from relatively close by the ongoing battle to get this film shot, edited and distributed and I can bear testimony of what a nightmare the process has been for Noel. He sold his house and used the money to make the film (and not starve whilst at it), but this is only a minor detail compared to all the disasters that befell on his way to having a feature film under his belt. If I had known, I would have shot a "making of", which would have compared well with "Lost in la Mancha", the main difference being that "Ausencia" finally made it to the theaters and on DVD's. And what justice is being done by allowing people to see this film! How talent and perseverance have resulted in a lush and utterly moving work of art. Where Almodovar captures from within the decadence and surrealism of Spain's capital Madrid, Noel has fallen in love with down to dry earth Andalusia. He offers us a unique and intimate view of real Andalusian people in their isolated world, while at the same time touching upon universal themes such as friendship, parenthood, coming of age, sexuality and betrayal. Set in the Arcadian landscape of springtime Southern Spain, the local actors (most of them young first time performers) behave as their own nature dictates, within the parameters of the story, closely directed by Noel. It is here that Noel excels: the visuals of the film are well above average of most Hollywood shows, the story is ingenuous and captivating, but the performances of the actors drawn out by intense direction are so direct and real that they touch the viewer as if he were participating in the story. Music (composed by Noel, who started pro life as a musician) beautifully accentuates and supports emotions evoked by the scenes, where impressionist images are followed by starkly realistic ones, although the film always draws upon our own imagination and experiences to complete the picture. A highly original film!
34 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A striking setting and unusual, ambiguous situation
Chris Knipp24 March 2009
The director says for this first film he gave his all, sold his house and spent $500,000 to make it with mostly non-actors in a beautiful part of Andalucia. Noel is good with the camera, with landscape, with improvisation, and with music, which he composed (he plays guitar). He uses simple elements, a mysterious man arriving with a broken-down car, a 13-year old boy missing a father, a flirty girl, a nosy postman--but the drama becomes quite complicated.

I'm not sure all the dots get connected or all final tragedies are necessary, but the ambiguous situation of the boy bonding with the man and the suspicious villagers feels original.

The director came to Spain (from where?) and settled in Andalucia 13 years ago to study Flamenco guitar. He has a recording studio, composes and plays multiple instruments, and also teaches music and drama in schools. The young actors in the film including his talented teen star Gonzalo Sanchez Salas, he trained in acting workshops for months before shooting the film.

'En tu ausencia' was in some festivals including Vancouver (2008) and Palm Springs (2009) but went straight to DVD in the US. It would be nice if Noel were able to make more features after this promising beginning.
18 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Few films are as good as this
berenshill17 August 2015
Wonderfully absorbing film, beautifully shot in southern Spain with some subtlety simple performances from what are by all accounts local people. The landscape compositions are that of a painter and the use of light outstanding. Yes, I really love this film.

It is a shame therefore to have to make adverse criticisms. The film was shot over a period of one year. That is a long time but especially so when your lead actor is eleven years old. Couple that with some glaring continuity errors: The boy's socks change colour within the same scene on several occasions.

As for the ambiguity I would not criticize that; it forces the viewer to think. I don't understand Spanish so I suspect I'm missing out on quite a lot, but then the film couldn't really have been made anywhere else, such are the locations so integral to the whole.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Tender Times
rikpaint13 June 2009
In Your Absence is a wonderful film that beautiful recreates that tender time when growing up is confusing and full of pain. Shot, remarkably on a very modest camera, with incredible composition this is a film as visually appealing as it is compelling. So many time we hear how the location is another character in a film, but this time one can really believe it, the stunning scenery is not just chocolate box cover imagery with actors plopped in front of it, but imagery that truly helps push the narrative forward. Cast with non-professional actors, who all live in around the same gorgeous hills and valleys where the story unfolds, they bring a credibility to this film that transcends normal improvised films. Ivan Noel has crafted a persuasive story with a cinematic style that is truly a love of labor. When one hears the director also wrote the script, composed the music, worked the camera and edit the film – one normally runs for the exit. But Ivan Noel deserves the title auteur. Put this on your must see list.
16 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An independent Spanish gem
wjajh12 November 2008
As a lover of the Andalusian countryside and people 'En Tu Ausenia' was an essential movie to see and I was not disappointed. The photography and rawness of the actors (all novices, I believe) added to a delicate coming of age storyline of family and human awareness, sensitively directed by Ivan Noel. The cast of locals brought such a natural realism to the story that at times I felt I was actually there! The music interpreted and complimented each scene so perfectly.. (I hope the music is one day released on CD) The visual beauty of the movie, along with the engaging storyline and creative directing (is Sr. Noel a cinematic disciple of Monet?)makes 'En Tu Ausenia' a must see ..especially for the followers of independent Spanish movies.
18 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
" The Ghosts which haunt us, arise from the Guilt we create "
thinker169115 April 2013
Movies' today are the results of someone's quest for entertainment. However, they can also reveal the universal search for truth which leaves an indelible impression on the human soul. Of all the inner virtues which have a duel purpose, Love is one which can either comfort or destroy those who seek it. And yet, it's the one power we have the least control over. This remarkable film was written and directed by the very talented Ivan Noel. The movie tells the moving story of Pablo Benitez (Gonzalo Sanchez Salas) who one day encounters a stranded stranger named Paco, (Francisco Alfonsin) who's car breaks down near his tiny village. Were it not for a very nosy postman (Antonio Sanchez) who begins to circulate rumors, few would know of the man's arrival. As it is, within days the entire population becomes aware of him. Adding to Pablo's daily life is Julia (Ana Tutor) who amuses herself with his friendship and sexual education. However, Paco's real reason for the arrival concerns Pablo's mother, (Anabel Azuar) one which Pablo is unaware of. The entire misunderstanding is sure to confuse the viewing audience, unless we pay close attention. The movie allows us to share the inner conflicts of youthful adolescence, challenged by life's decisions concerning Love, hate and the trapping of innocent mistakes. This being Salas' first movie, it is easy to understand how he gives such a powerful performance with such youthful exuberance. Indeed, the entire cast should be proud of their efforts. Their combined talents with the guidance of their creative, masterful and artistic director have assured us with a visual Masterpiece which in time will be seen as a true Classic. ****
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The most professional indie film I have seen.
gerryfashion9 March 2010
I read a so-called 'review' below, which seems inspired by some bizarre personal grudge, rather than lucidity. Better they stick to 'Spiderman', and leave indie reviews for others. I have followed the course of this spectacularly beautiful film since it first came out. But just sticking to facts: I doubt the film would have been selected over tens of thousands of other films in the most important festivals of the world, if it had been 'amateur'! What a silly comment. Seattle, Vancouver, Palm Springs, it was voted one of the top films in Vancouver. Reviews have been outstanding right across the board, by professional critics in various countries. What is most striking about the film is the amazing naturalness of the acting, which they all refer to. So when one refers to 'skit' level acting, it is clear they are either an envious failed director, or have another agenda. The screenplay itself is one of the most sensitive portrayals of youth I have come across, full of subtleties, which, yes, I can see some more 'hollywood-style' persons might not catch on to. Well done Mr Noel, and ignore the sub-standard reviews like the one below. IMDb is a free and very 'popular' medium where the lowest minds even try to contribute. If the trailer is anything to go by, his second film looks to be even more promising. I'll leave you with what they said on the films first showing: 'Director Noel shoots the gloriously sunlit countryside around the village of Jerez with the eye of a painter while showing his expertise at playing with audience expectations. It is this sure-handed way with what turns out to be a surprising narrative, the naturalism of the local townspeople in their first acting roles, and the almost dangerous sensuality of the cinematography, that marks In Your Absence as a very impressive first film.'
24 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Stand alone gem
taner8625 March 2009
In the context of the "world wide cinema" intellectual recession - this film stands out as a gem. The movie must not be told in any details prior to watching it-is my view. Comments around the technical aspect of movie making should be harmless though: Having to disposal high tech digital equipment these days - I would have expected more of an art work/play around the nude scenes, body shapes and more attention to lighting elsewhere. At this level of an art - more play with lights would further benefit the overall appearance of the movie which otherwise is well outside of the guttersnipes' consumption anyway. At times the contrasts on faces were on the "sharp side of things". Employing "counter soft" lighting would give that extra feel of excellently made portraits. That's on technical side of things. The film stands still firm at 10 points though since “Rambo” style movies gets also the same scores :-). Majority of films on the subject are made based on the far reaching consultations with the psycho/sociological professional teams. The result of such “out of touch with reality” studies is always a sterile movie. Such movies are indeed analytical at best. To describe this movie as such ( as i read here and there) is a brave business to provoke to be laughed at. In my view, it is not possible to make this movie without the natural inspiration on the theme flowing from within the director's heart. It almost feels as if it is an autobiographical story although the director doesn’t say that. How otherwise one could know what is inside an adolescent ripped apart by the fate. And all of it in such minute details? This film is what an art is all about and it is great news to hear that the director is working on another movie around the same theme. In the event - I can’t wait to see his "Brecha". ”En tu aucencia” is an absolute must to see. Well, at least by the better part of our society members.
15 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Some questions
kev17-885-80443231 December 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Did Pablo intentionally withdraw the ladder or had not he seen that his father was on the roof of the home? Does Pablo see in the stranger a father of substitution or did he feel for him an "homosexual" attraction? Did Julia tease the postman and was her consenting(anyway it is a sexual abuse) or was it a rape? Thank you for answers and excuse my bad English.

Decors and pictures of this film sound splendid. Comments are very sober but very significant. The character of Julia is is possible be too much caricature. I do not believe a 14-year-old girl be able to act so? Stage of the pseudo rape under the eyes of the grandfather is a bit" borderline" .The character of Pablo is very lovable. I deeply recommend this film.
7 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
When adults play with the feelings of a boy, it can only end badly
Didachos18 May 2024
Warning: Spoilers
"En tu ausencia" (In your absence) is a 2008 film by Spanish director Ivan Noel. It was actually his first film, to make which he sold his house and most of his belongings. The talented director has wonderfully impressed on the film - as a painter would have done on his canvas - the wonderful sunlit landscape of the countryside around the small hilltop village of Ubrique, near Jerez, located in the astonishing Andalusia (southern Spain)

Equally surprising is the acting naturalness of the locals - all at their first experience - and above all that one of the very young Gonzalo Sánchez Salas who plays the protagonist, Pablo, and grows physically with him: in fact filming took a year because the director wanted to capture the changing seasons and landscape, reflecting the mood and thoughts of the protagonists (so the boy starts playing his character at age 11 and finishes at 12).

Pablo Gonzales is a 13-year-old who lives in the countryside quite far from the village and from the boys of his age; Pablo has no other way to spend his summer days wandering alone in the open air running, jumping and doing things that you can do only at his age. Sometimes he practices with his father's rifle.

He has a friend who lives not far from him, Julia, a cheeky fifteen-year-old who casually helps Pablo in the transition from childhood to adolescence, giving him some "advice" even on sex (ok, more practical examples than advice, I must say) .

One day, while wandering through the fields, Pablo meets a man, Paco (played by Francisco Alfonsin), whose car broke down there, in the middle of nowhere. The man asks Pablo if he can help him start the car while he fiddles in the engine compartment, but it's no use, the car won't start.

The local postman, who arrived on his bicycle, also offers to help, but he can't do it either. To the postman's specific question, Paco replies that he is from northern Spain, remaining suspiciously vague about the precise location. That's why, having gone far enough, the postman, with an excuse, brings Pablo closer and tells him to go home and not stay with that unknown man.

Pablo doesn't listen to him at all and stays there with the man who asks him if he can take him to the village mechanic who goes to the site with them and, after a check, tells Paco that the car must be taken to his garage and that he will need a few days to find spare parts. Paco thanks him and tells him that an old friend of his lives in the area, even if he doesn't remember exactly where: they served together in the army and he has been looking for him for many years. When he reveals his name - what an incredible coincidence! - that friend is Pablo's father!

When the mechanic has left, Paco asks Pablo if he can take him to his father. While they're walking to the village, Paco tells him about his friendship with his father. The boy listens with his head down, sad. When they reach a decadent cemetery, Pablo enters and heads towards a tombstone: Paco now understands that his old friend was dead and bursts into tears.

Paco asks Pablo how it happened and the boy vaguely replies that he fell and died after three weeks in hospital. Pablo describes his father as an exceptional man, very close to him and who loved his son. And if his father punished him, it was because he was scatterbrained and his father wanted to raise him well.

But while the boy states these things, his flashbacks make his father appear different, far from be kind to his son, whom he often punished harshly and heratless in someway. Like when his father forced him to drown his dog who had caused damage in the chicken coop.

Oddily enough, Paco seems to know things he shouldn't be supposed to know about Pablo's life. In particular, he tells him that anyone has his own secrets and has done things in life to regret about. He tells the boy: «no matter if you have made mistakes in the past: you are guilty of nothing; you are a good boy.» Something truly precise, not random.

The fact is that Pablo, despite his very young age, really has something to regret about. In fact another flashback let us realize that it was Pablo who accidentally caused his father's death: the man is on the roof to repair some tiles and Pablo come and get the ladder on where the man had one of his feet, whithout seeing him at all. The man falls to the ground, suffering serious injuries that will lead to his death.

Paco's very affectionate attitude towards Pablo make the boy begin to feel a strong bond with him, but it is something that seems to go slightly beyond simple friendship: the following day Pablo and Paco are at the lake: once out of the water, the boy strips completely naked and lay down right in front of Paco, almost luring him. Paco invites Pablo to get dressed because it is not an appropriate behavior. So Pablo does it.

After a while arrives the postman (always him) to tell Paco that his car is fixed, then he leave. Paco and Pablo also leave and Paco tells Pablo that now he has to leave forever. The boy, very sad, tells him he must stay, he can live at his house; but the man smiles and tells that it is not possible.

In the meantime, the mechanic's son drown in the lake while he's playing with two friends, who deadly scared, tell the adults that they don't know what's happened, but they had seen Paco there. The postman that had seen him there with Pablo short before, put the blame on Paco for the boy's death.

Pablo returns home to grab his rifle and sees Paco's hat hanging in the entrance. He come close to his mother's bedroom whose door is slightly open and sees her in bed with Paco, both naked. Paco is saying that it was easy with Pablo who in only two days ended asking him to live at his house. He also says that Pablo is a good boy but he is a bit strange, different... like "a little queer".

So it became clear that the two had known each other and had been lovers for some time. It is all too evident that everything was organized from the beginning by the two lovers to make sure that Pablo could become very close to Paco and could thus accept him as his stepfather.

What he saw and heard causes Pablo's anger to explode and he start to shout insults at Paco, running away in the courtyard. Totally out of his mind, he points his rifle at Paco, who has just come out. The man tries to calm and disarm him. In the meantime, the postman, just arrived, snatches the rifle from Pablo hands and then shoots Paco who collapses in a pool of blood.

Pablo is terrified and in tears; his mother kneels over her lover's body, regardless of her son who is totally shocked repeating "dad, dad" - as if he were reliving his father's death - and then runs away towards the lake where he sits down and bursts into endless tears.

Once this dramatic scene has faded, a leap of several years, takes us in the present: Paco did not die, but the serious injuries suffered bring him in a wheelchair. The man tells an adult Pablo the whole story for the first time: both he and his friend (Pablo's father) loved the same woman (Pablo's mother). But when Pablo was born she marries Pablo's father who "wins" the love dispute between friend. After her husband's death, Pablo's mother called Paco because she still loved him and conv9ince him to move at her's. And we know the rest.

Paco tells absent Pablo that he doesn't blame him for what happened, after all he was just a child. As if the fault did not lie exclusively with the two adults who had concocted such a selfish and cruel plan, which meant to play with the feelings of a child who had recently lost his father and for whose death he felt guilty.

While Paco is still talking, Pablo leaves without having said even a word and letting the man alone with his ghosts and his selfiness.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed