This felt very true to the original series while still being slightly more adult. I definitely did not recognize Guppy and doubt anyone did despite the SNL style applause during his appearance.
4 Reviews
iCarly at its best
masterpoliwhirl8 April 2022
A wacky storyline with great heart. The jokes were great. Carly messing up the "Your Honor" thing was really cute humor. It's good to have some familiar faces back like Chuck, Lewbert and Guppy and while this episode did lean a bit on nostalgia factor it didn't feel intrusive. The Carly/Freddie/Spencer-line worked pretty well and I loved Freddie's facial expressions during his hearing. The Harper/Millicent/Olive-line was really cute and feel like the old tween comedies from the 2000's presented with a lot of charm. All in all a great start of the second season combined with the previous episode.
Episode was a rollercoaster of emotions!
kelvin-4932115 April 2022
i must be missing something
JoeyLeblanc854 May 2022
Not funny at all. I didn't laugh once and i was high when i watched. They rely too much on nostalgia and the jokes are just so 'meh' and predictable it's like "this character is here" "and this character also" "remember that episode of the original show?" is like i'm watching this reboot just for the sake of remembering the original, which we all know was so much better. Still don't know if i liked the first season, but i'm definitely not a fan of this one. Icarly used to be such an escape of the world we're in, now is just throwing it in our faces (and doesn't even have the decency of putting good jokes to come with it)
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
