"I Shouldn't Be Alive" A Family's Desert Hell (TV Episode 2011) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
What did I just watch? These people just wanted to die?
JurijFedorov20 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Sooo many mistakes. It's nice to see survival episodes with people who somewhat want to save themselves. But here you see a mother and step-dad who are absolutely clueless about even basic survival skills. Basically everything they do is completely wrong and just gets them into greater danger. This hurts to watch, but this is pretty much how normal 100 IQ people would act in such situations. It's a cringe factory. They go into the desert on a picnic with her 2 small girls in a car.

Firstly, they go the wrong way in the desert. Instead of trying to find the right way out they try to cross a dried up stream in their way. So they need to take their 2-wheel drive car down a small hill. It gets stuck, obviously, and they are so useless that they can't get it unstuck. This stuff is not simple and could take hours, but it's just weird they seemingly give up very fast here. This car is life and death.

Then we uncover that they have just 1 phone and it wasn't charged. So they can't even call for help! We are talking about 2 adults taking 2 small girls into the desert and the mom didn't even check to see if the phone was charged. This alone is baffling.

Then we discover that they only have a few liters of water or less for 4 people! Whaaaaat??? They are going into the desert with no extra water? So if their car broke down anywhere they would need to either hope the phone would work or that someone would find them. They could be dead in 2 days easily in scorching hot heat. This is not even about survival this is just pure thinking skills failing. Then instead of staying put or send 1 adult to the big roads they all decide to walk towards some desert roads during the day. At night they sleep. So when they have walking conditions they sleep, when it's unbearably hot they walk. The 2 girls could walk 4 miles in 4 hours at the very start. That shows you how stupid a plan it was. During the night they probably could easily walk to a big road. During the day they could have found some shadow to sleep under.

But of course there is a reason they don't want to walk at night. Human smugglers from Mexico try to kill the people they meet in this desert. So when they spot a car at night it nearly drives over them. Yep, she took her daughters to a place where you could get killed at night. They even said that you can't be there at night. So I'm not even sure what they planned for such a situation.

At the end the mother and the daughters are too tired to walk. So they just lay down. Instead of laying down near a road she is far away and a car searching for them drives by without spotting them. I mean, at this point it's like she wants to kill her family. Everything they did was bafflingly silly or insane. Just the reason for being out there makes no sense. And being so unprepared makes me think that it's not a thinking family.

It's nearly unbearable. They survive by luck. Poor daughters. But it's a strong episode. In other episodes you have divers survive at sea or climbers survive in a mountain. Here you have a regular family just make up things as they go along.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Amazing survival but the adults are hard to sympathize with
OneAnjel27 January 2024
I've watched a number of episodes in this series along with a lot of other survival type docudramas. I normally don't review episodes individually, but in this case I felt compelled because of the incredible ineptitude of the adults involved. I realize the series itself isn't in place to try to pick apart all the details or identify shortcomings in those involved. But here we have a woman who claims to have been to this area of the desert for years. That part, I do understand because when families are very poor they do find unusual activities to entertain themselves with. What I didn't understand was why they didn't have more provisions and why, being out in the desert, would you use water to wash your hands? Why would you allow your inexperienced boyfriend to attempt to drive a two-wheel drive truck over a riverbed that you hadn't come in over and don't know where it's going to lead? And as the other review here points out, why would you walk during the day and try to sleep at night? But mainly why would you leave the only working vehicle even if it was stuck in a ditch? Only one person needed to go back and check the abandoned truck for supplies. And why didn't they go back to their truck where at least they would survive in air conditioning until the gas ran out? I mean there are so many things that went wrong here. It appeared as if they were not rationing food or water that first day and they didn't have any hiking boots in the vehicle or any supplies in case something went wrong in the freaking desert? I live in a town near the Pacific ocean with mountains all around and I keep a go-bag in my trunk that has everything you could possibly need for survival including a whistle, flares, Mylar covers, a shovel & a solor powered cellphone charger. I mean, it is a true miracle that any of them survived.

The other review claims the average IQ is 100 but the truth is most people who make up the census represent only around 60% of the US poulation. The other 40% have an average between 89 - 92, which varies widely depending on factors like home life, addiction or so forth. I think the mom and boyfriend fall in that 40% category.

I guess a lot of people could say, well you don't know what you would do in the same situation. But I know what I wouldn't do: I wouldn't take small children into a desert without sufficient supplies; I wouldn't take them traipsing through 118° heat when I have a working truck engine for shelter; I wouldn't head in the same direction that someone already was going since going in a different direction would form two chances of coming across someone who can help; I wouldn't go off the road without having my gun ready to fire if a car does come by or place any kind of flag to indicate my location. I mean, it's almost unbelievable that people would live so close to this deadly place and yet have so little understanding of its most famous qualities. God certainly wasn't ready to end their lives.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed