Among Giants (2011) Poster

(2011)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Don't Be Cynical
Theo Robertson28 February 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Environmentalism is a bit like communism . Great idea in theory but constantly let down by its adherents . I should perhaps put my hand up to something . I was once a member of the Scottish Green Party for a couple of years but left due to 9/11 and its aftermath where the party faithful seemed to think mass murder caused by theocrats was somehow justified while the response to this atrocity by secular democratic governments was heavy handed . I hasten to add I'm referring to the NATO intervention in Afghanistan which was sanctioned by the UN and not the Anglo-American invasion of Iraq ( I'd long left the party by then ) and concluded that Quaker based environmentalism was exactly as described by George Orwell , a strange cult that is only anti-war when war is waged by democracies against tyranny . I was also a member of Greenpeace for a couple of years but was told to not bother attending any more meetings after arguing with certain members of the organization hierarchy , a hierarchy that functioned exactly like a corporate company . You can appreciate the irony and you can perhaps appreciate why I tend to be cynical against the environmental movement . They are their own worst enemies , and while I still hold environmental leanings due to scientific readings and other empirical evidence I see many environmentalists as beneath contempt

This documentary revolves around Farmer who on seeing a timber company cutting the local redwood forest decides to do something about it . You don't need a erstwhile closet hippy like myself to tell you about redwood trees . While a redwood tree was a mere sapling the Europeans were still worshipping Pagan gods like Thor and Odin . They had stood for centuries and are now being chopped down so Farmer decides if he makes a stand the timber company will stop . He does this by living on top of a tree I'm not sure if it's a good thing but there's not a lot of dialogue . I would have liked to hear more about Farmer the person and his motives but there might have been a slight danger in to turning Farmer's story in to a diatribe . As it is Farmer comes across as a likable enough chap and visuals and audio tell the story . The sound mix as Farmer sits in a tree in a plastic shelter and gets bombarded by torrential rain leading to a constant white noise as the rain splashes off the plastic gives an indication of some of the hardship endured on a principal . The fact that there's little dialogue does give you a short taste of the bitter loneliness of solitude involved in this campaign

Even though it's a documentary I should guard my back against the guidelines of IMDb and have included a spoiler tag and that is there's a happy ending to this story down to Farmer and his colleagues . So well done that chap and if I ever meet you I'll shake your hand and buy you drink . One man can make the world a better place
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A very well shot nature short for what it does well, even if I left little the wiser
bob the moo2 March 2014
Although I am quite liberal, I must admit that bad experiences with people have very much put my back up against the traditional "tree- hugger" movement. While some make great sacrifices for what they believe, I do find that some of them seem to go to great lengths to show you how much better they are for it and rather than reaching out to the masses they seem to deliberately push away. Anyway, I say this up front just because this film is about one of the group of people who lived up the very top of giant redwood trees in an attempt to stop a logging company clearing them. The trees are hundreds of years old in most cases and even I can see the loss of destroying them to create products that may last a hundred years if they are lucky.

When watching shorts, I find it is sometimes unfair to watch without context as to what the goals of the film were but it is also difficult to always find that context due to the small nature of the films. In this case the film succeeds in giving us some beautiful nature shots (in particular some helicopter shots) but also giving us a feel for the isolation and boredom of the sacrifice. There is very little dialogue and generally the main noise is the constant drizzle on the tarpaulin and the wind howling by high in the trees. Farmer himself is quiet and doesn't say much and again this adds to the feeling. So on that front it works but the problem is that it doesn't really tell us too much. I am grateful that the film didn't get on its soapbox about the topic but just presented nature, but I would have liked some more information and would in particular have liked a bit more exploring of Farmer as a person, rather than just sitting back off him. What about him finds him up this tree, what are his plans, what of his family that he says he misses etc, it would have been nice to have some nuggets in there along with the silence.

So, as a nature short filled with images, silence and isolation it works really well, but it would have been nice to have left the short at least a little wiser about Farmer or at least the issues behind the film.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed